S.Milne - Maybe time to go. Reasonable 30 goal return, however his value could pull together a fair trade for the right player e.g Milne for Seaby? Straight swap for mine. :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: I don't like that, maybe get them to throw in Judd just to even that trade up

I like him more in the back half...

not only is he a good defensive player but he forces his opponent up the ground to be accountable...

the kind of player who could drift down and bang a goal from 50 out

Just thought I'd have a little look at some of the ex-saints that have been running around recently and the trades we got for them... Trent Knobel: He left for nothing and his career nose dived accordingly. His form with us probably better than any of our current ruckman to date. Pbly would have bee...

It appeared that our core list peaked from about 2004-06 In those years Port, Bris, Adel, Wce and Syd to a lesser degree always looked a bit like the unstoppable jaggurnuat teams. We all felt that once the finals started it would be extremely tough to beat any of these teams interstate... This year,...

OUT
Thompson
Gehrig
Raymond
Sweeney
Brooks
Gwilt
Voss
Doc

Demote
Wall

Promote
Geary

Ferguson and McQualter saved by the skin of their teeth simply because of the mass exodus and the fact that there are no queries over their training and work ethics

Plan RE Harvey

why not have him stay on the list and not play until the finals next season (unless he wants to)

would anybody care

Barks, agree with you on most things except I don't rate Rix any higher than Doc.

Why do think Jason Blake continually gets games?

Here's what I think will happen We'll get 2 ruckman to replace M. Clarke and Brooks. Pbly one through the draft and maybe a young up and comer berift of opportunity. hopes will predominantly rest with Gardiner for next season Our stocks down back generally don't look too bad. Hudghton, Maguire, Fish...

I'm thinking Attard but I don't know

anything official yet?

I got the same e-mail from AF

nothing official but i'll add my 2 cents

IMO Kosi loves the club, his friends are here, it has been very good to him and he seems like a very loyal person...

i don't think he would go to a rabble like carrrrlllllllton, for money alone

Gwilts performance down back earlier in the year is quite possibly the most overated set of games any individual has played he was consistently caught behind and unable to spoil. it was only because the Fisher brotehrs, Gram and every other player in the vicinity dropped back to play 2-3 on 1 footy ...

Posts like this make me embarrased about our supporters. Are you guys all this one eyed? What about Ben Johnson? He got 6 weeks and Roe got 1. We aren't the only club to get dodgy tribunal deals. Lets move on. i would have thought BJ got a pretty good deal and the Roe one was not as bad... worth 2-...

This guy leads hard... stops suddenly and changes direction (full speed) and leads again...

only a matter of time until he stops and his opponent ploughs into him and BAM... 5 week suspension for Nick Riewoldt

SR, i think he means Max has never really looked like he's regained full fitness and looks like he could break down for 5-6 weeks at any minute

WCE have a very good 2nd tier of midfielders... we could maybe tag one but the bottom line is to win the game, we need at least beat half of them.


i wouldn't want to have more than one tagger in the team... Baker on Kerr and let Hayes and Cousins go for their lives.

he's an ex-player that was pbly tagged by Baker throughout some part of his career...

i wouldn't trust his word

we need fast midfielders and tough enforcer midfielders

whilst a good player I don't think he excells at either categories

it's not always the case but in this instance i would attribute Fiora's improvement to the coach.

he looks to me like he's playing a more specific role and not relying on his postion and his skills to dictate the way he plays

he backs himself a lot more

influeces games when it matters

lol, i read the first 1/2 of that with a look of utter contempt on my face b4 i figured out it was a joke... it's written very journalistically until u quote Anderson

fair enough

any coincidence that his best game of the season comes after he gets some decent match fitness under his belt???

his last stint was a suicide mission and i'll stand by that

does anyone else suspect that teflon and barks are the same person???

Was One on One, with a bloke called Heath Black 4 times today.......won three of the contests.....drew one... Interesting to see the supposed 'hard nosed Black' running around behind the pill getting handball recieves...............whilst 'fiona' was running through the middle, generating play....b...