Not sure he deserved another crack, but good luck to him all the same

This thread is hilarious. The bloke is not fit enough He has not reached his potential at all Yes he has had collision injuries, yes he is courageous. Just because you question his work ethic, doesn’t mean you question his ability. He should be an a grader and he’s not, and he’s not because I don’t ...

Rays biggest issue is that he kicked floaters
Long kick but took too long to get there

Joyce was a complete liability every time he played afl

Can’t see Webster getting a game personally - we have moved passed him I think

Paton-Howard-Battle
Clark-Wilkie-NWM (or Sinclair if not midfield)

And then you have Coffield and Highmore as well.
Think Webster is 8th in line for a back 6 spot

Cordy will not be playing seniors surely

I think Howard is one player Lyon will help a lot. Look for him to be a big improver next year.

From what I have read and seen

Mackenzie is very good at most things but not elite.
He has shot in the draft boards in a week draft.

As others have said Phillipou and Humphrey are riskier but have elite attributes.

Reckon Humphrey will be gone by our pick.

B.M wrote: ↑Tue 25 Oct 2022 11:51pm Curious

What year did you expect Richardson to make finals?

Every year

Really.
Do we have to post the past again and again
I thought coaches don’t matter, why do you care

I cannot believe how much people undervalue Bowes, he is a good player with strong skills ready to break out imo
I think he is a mid as well

Of course they haven’t because we haven’t
You can’t get closer than a draw, but hey…
Stanley might get dropped yet

And we have club captains in Hamill and Steele
Vice captain in membrey
Coleman medalist in Gehrig
Nearly norm Smith medalist gram
Excellent players in Dempster and Schneider and voss

Etc etc

Every club has them come in and go out
We only focus on one way

No top 10 pick - he doesn’t leave
Simple
Hold him to the contract

Clark is not a good ball user, he should be and can be, but he is not.
He turns the ball over too much, both by possession and getting caught in possession.
Yes he has had injuries but he should have improved more by now.
Is that st kildas development capabilities or is it him?
I wonder

Clark plus something for Ben King
Is it our first round pick, another player, swap of picks?
Suddenly Gold Coast may have too many tall forwards and Ben is coming off a knee

100% why do the deal
Back Hayes in to turn him around
He leaves for a shuffle of picks at the top end or he stays
He gets tagged most weeks, that’s how valuable other teams see him

Possible trade
Swap north pick 1 for our pick 9 plus Hill
We split pick 1 into pick 7 and say 13
We split 13 into 18 and 30
We get 3 picks inside 30

And yes north could do the swap of pick 1 and give us pick 13 instead

North drop a few spots and get hill

Only possible if clarko gets there obviously

Jeans at Richmond Jeans at St Kilda? Was Jeans a great coach at StKilda? Did he get the best out of his talent base? Did Jeans cost us the 1971 flag by not making a move on Keddie? Keddie kicked 4 last quarter goals and missed two sitters. I bet the 1971 fan forum went into melt down that night on ...

B.M wrote: ↑Mon 01 Aug 2022 7:26pm Cal Wilkie is a massive chance for the B&F

A Wilkie Sinclair tie would be appropriate

He was clean today, didn’t fumble
Looked positive, lead up to the ball
For me played a good game, reckon his best for the year
When he doesn’t fumble he is good

I thought we played like absolute sh*t in the second half (not the first time this season), but reading comments here, it looks like the umpires caused us to lose. It is possible to have umpires change momentum twice but also have our players fold like a deck of cards and lose the game. We were cle...

Time for some left field thinking
Ben King is still there ready and waiting

How about
Hunter Clark and our first pick for Ben.
He goes back and dominates CHB and Clark goes to GC in his favoured HB which they need?

Would we do it?
Would they take it?

It is not a legal possession if it brushes your foot, they have been paying them holding the ball all year.

That decision and the arm chop by Wilkie were massive errors by the same umpire and changed the momentum of the game both times.

Scollop wrote: ↑Sat 02 Jul 2022 12:40am

Waltzing St Kilda wrote: ↑Sat 02 Jul 2022 12:00am Thought NWM deserves a Rising Star nod.

+1

+2