WindSister wrote:trade 5 for 9&13 ... keep em both ... give the dons 24 or hello psd.
... whats wrong with that ?

I like it

It's poor list management by both Essendon and Collingwood that have put them in this position of no bargaining power. As a club, you have the opportunity to extend players contracts. If you let their contract run down, or they refuse to resign - that's you're mistake or issue as a club. We've gone ...

"The whole appeal of Freeman is that we can get him cheap in the 'HOPE' of him getting his body right". Exactly saintjake, If Freeman gets over his injuries then whoo hoo! Of coarse Coll wants Acers. St.K drop the ball if Freeman doesn't come on safer grounds. Sounds like Aish will not la...

Being reported that the 'Pies are interested in Acres as well. I really like the look of Acres, and he's got a long term contract. But if the right deal came.....I dunno?? It would need to be something like Freeman & a 2nd round pick for Acres. But the 'Pies would never cough that up. No. Freem...

Superfooty just posted an article on twitter saying Adelaide might be able to save Essendon/Carlisle andhelp get a deal done. In the article they said that the Saints are currently offering pick 24 and are also willing to do pick 24 and a player. Superfooty's solution was that Saints trade 5 to Ade...

Being reported that the 'Pies are interested in Acres as well. I really like the look of Acres, and he's got a long term contract. But if the right deal came.....I dunno?? It would need to be something like Freeman & a 2nd round pick for Acres. But the 'Pies would never cough that up. No. Freem...

Being reported that the 'Pies are interested in Acres as well. I really like the look of Acres, and he's got a long term contract. But if the right deal came.....I dunno?? It would need to be something like Freeman & a 2nd round pick for Acres. But the 'Pies would never cough that up. No. Freem...

Superfooty just posted an article on twitter saying Adelaide might be able to save Essendon/Carlisle andhelp get a deal done. In the article they said that the Saints are currently offering pick 24 and are also willing to do pick 24 and a player. Superfooty's solution was that Saints trade 5 to Ade...

Superfooty just posted an article on twitter saying Adelaide might be able to save Essendon/Carlisle andhelp get a deal done. In the article they said that the Saints are currently offering pick 24 and are also willing to do pick 24 and a player. Superfooty's solution was that Saints trade 5 to Adel...

Where is Jaxsons or tony74?

Swap of picks with Adelaide Hickey to the swans for a first rounder Hopefully end up with 2 first rounders and Carlilse Wht would Hickey go to Sydney when the reason why he came to Melbourne was his GF? Because he can get game time. And not chill in the seconds or be forced to try and be a forward/...

Swap of picks with Adelaide Hickey to the swans for a first rounder Hopefully end up with 2 first rounders and Carlilse Wht would Hickey go to Sydney when the reason why he came to Melbourne was his GF? Because he can get game time. And not chill in the seconds or be forced to try and be a forward/...

Swap of picks with Adelaide

Hickey to the swans for a first rounder
Hopefully end up with 2 first rounders and Carlilse

2 deals need to happen with other clubs not involving us and that will open up a real chance to nab another young gun from another club that will tie in to our pick 5 & 24. Possible we give up 5 & 24 for Carlisle, Freeman and young gun. 3 jets with our first 2 picks in a shallow draft. Woul...

Having debates on Facebook with Easendon fans. I don't understand how they can actually think 5 is a good deal for Carlisle. He doesn't want to be there. He is out of contract. Didn't even get a top 10 in their B&F Has nominated us. What cards to Essendon actually hold? WHY would we give up 5 fo...

- Trade Hickey/Longer for a first round pick (many teams looking for a Ruckman) - Use the pick we receive for either Hickey or Longer for Carlisle - Second or Third rounder for Freeman - Pick 5 and next years second rounder (or player) for Treloar Any realistic chance? This will leave us very thin ...

- Trade Hickey/Longer for a first round pick (many teams looking for a Ruckman)
- Use the pick we receive for either Hickey or Longer for Carlisle
- Second or Third rounder for Freeman
- Pick 5 and next years second rounder (or player) for Treloar


Any realistic chance?

- Trade Hickey/Longer for a first round pick (many teams looking for a Ruckman)
- Use the pick we receive for either Hickey or Longer for Carlisle
- Second or Third rounder for Freeman
- Pick 5 and next years second rounder (or player) for Treloar


Any realistic chance?

- I really do believe that one of Longer or Hickey will be traded for a first round pick this year (probably Hickey) - Before you all say the inevitable "Hickey/Longer isn't worth a first round pick" please understand that ready made ruckman and very hard to come by - which makes them exp...

Pyke going to retire tonight from the Swans

Longer/Hickey to Sydney for their first pick.

Sydney's first pick for Carlisle

Carlisle to be second ruckman next year, not Bruce.

Boom

Bunk Moreland or whoever is suggesting that a good deal for Carlisle is

JC and 23 for Billings and 5!!!


You have to be taking the piss Bunk!

magnifisaint wrote:

saintjake wrote:JOM will be returning to Melbourne, wants to live in Melbourne, wants to start his property portfolio - purchased something in St.Kilda recently. He won't be at GC in 2017

He is originally from WA

I never said he wanted to go home. I said he wants to live in Melbourne

JOM will be returning to Melbourne, wants to live in Melbourne, wants to start his property portfolio - purchased something in St.Kilda recently. He won't be at GC in 2017

Does anyone here rate Jay Clarke from the Hearld Sun? He was the one that tweeted possibly Billings for Carlisle. And in a Q&A today someone asked him who the Saints would have to give up if they were going to keep pick 5 and get Carlisle and he said Acres. He can't be serious can he? For mine h...

Just watched his video for his draft year before he was drafted.. Can't say I see what all the excitement is about. Looks like he is quick, but with average disposal. Steven gets smashed on here for his disposal.. Freeman looks very similar. Is the excitement just because a top 10 pick has nominated...