darylcowie wrote: ↑Mon 08 May 2023 1:58pm So you're all prepared to accept that Higgins set-shot goalkicking will keep being a lottery then?

So who do you replace him with?

Correct me if I’m wrong but he is our highest goal kicker for the year and had more shots on goal than any other forward yesterday.

Yes..... the answer is yes

The way I looked at yesterday's game is, our goal kicking let us down early and we should have had a 5 goal plus lead at 1/2 time. The longer the Roo's were in the game the more Clarkson dropped players behind the ball and made it bloody ugly. We should have been better looking for better inside 50 ...

skeptic wrote: ↑Mon 08 May 2023 1:52pm Crouch’s output or perhaps his effectiveness has dropped markedly for three weeks and a great start to the year

i don't think it's a coincidence that Crouch's output has dipped since Steele has come back in.
He is spending less time in the Centre bounces which is his bread and butter.

Crazy to think that someone who is coming off a lengthy injury and being asked to play a role he isn’t suited to, is out of form. He will be back when he is able to move away from FF and play on guys that don’t monster him.

Just because they are all smallish forwards (to a degree) we do understand they all play different roles yeah? It’s not like the three of them are there to do the same thing. Gresham is playing a hybrid half forward/midfield role, Higgins has been used as more of a marking target up forward and Butl...

5 Wilkie
4 Stocker
3 Byrnes
2 Owens
1 Clark

5 Marshall
4 Sinclair
3 Wanganeen - Milera
2 Wood
1 Stocker

Byrnes over Billings Paton over Webster Cordy over King Those three in over these liabilities and we win. I don’t understand your dislike for Byrnes. The kid has been a jet this year. Brings some much needed pace to our line up and his disposal is nowhere as bad as you make out. I notice no umpire ...

Looks like he needs a rest. Just a kid coming off his first pre season, some tough games and a five day break. Can’t blame him.

Outcoached? Don’t think so.
We lost on effort, legs and skills.
Although skills mainly because we looked slow and tired. Resorted to bombing into the forward line, which I put down to not being fresh after a five day break.

Clearly his spot in the team is only insurance if Marshall goes down during the game. We can’t have Owen’s rucking all game. Will eventually make way for Caminiti and then King. But I suspect may even make way next week.

I only boo him because he didn’t deserve to be Australian of the year.

We looked tired and therefore lazy. I think this game was lost in selection. Not bringing in some fresh legs after two hard games and a 5 day turn around hurt us. Even so we stayed in the fight all things considered. I don’t understand Cordy’s role? 1 kick and 3 hit outs in 3 quarters is not good en...

FFS he is a kid. I find the mindset of middle aged men booing a 19 year old kid quite pathetic and sad.

And those who are saying that his stats are also boosted by kick outs.
He averages 3.5 kick outs per game.
Kid is a gun - no questions asked!

Just quietly his Brother goes alright too.
People who claim he gets cheap touches etc need to understand that every team needs that player. It’s what he does with those touches that is outstanding.

14-4 by round 18 I’d take.
But who do we lose the other 3 games against.

Paton is a liability with the ball. Cordy is a witches hat.

The_Dud wrote: ↑Sun 23 Apr 2023 4:52pm I’ve had about enough of Gresham…

FFS he has hit Membrey and Marshall on the lead with two awesome kicks. Kept the ball alive which resulted in Woods goal.

Was interviewed in the Social Club last week and said he hoped to be back in the backend of the season. Didn’t sound good. Made it very clear that there is no timeline at the moment

5 Wilkie
4 Battle
3 Crouch
2 Clark
1 Wood

For me - todays game showed me we are finals bound. Wasn’t convinced before today.

Was poor. Not sure Coffield is ahead of him but Webster certainly is.

2 weeks plus StKilda tax = 4 weeks with an early plea