um how about NO! Chips is very important to our structure.. we can not lose him! We need him. I couldn't have said it better myself.... NO NO NO NO NOOOOOOO I don't want a bloody 1st round draft pick for chips and then have to wait 2 or 3 years for that player to get 50 plus games under his belt.

ahhh i only wish it was happening to Geelong, then i would be really happy ....

scumbags

Woot Woot, YES i am going to the game this weekend, Finally get to head to the dome for the first time this year. (have not been since the robbie concert. Also havn't been to a game since round 1 and it would be great to catch up with some of the mob. Anyone interested in a pre game drink at livewire?

Gehrig - If his lack of passion is anything to go by then I can't see him going on, agree with OWTS, not apart of our next flag. lack of passion...? playing with injured hand, injured foot, working his backside off defensively whilst getting 0 help offensively and he is dispassionate? what are you ...

Q: Are these players finished? 36 - Robert Harvey................ YES (saddens me to say it, but he won't be part of our next flag) 34 - Andrew Thompson.......... YES 34 - Matthew Clarke............... YES 31 - Fraser Gehrig.................. YES (won't be part of our next flag) 30 - Aaron Hamill.....

Congrats to Dal on that awesome achievement



Oh brother, any achievement/milestone games, WE SUCK AT THEM
don't count harves 350th, they owed him that.

fonz_#15 I am with you 100%, hamstrings, fingers, toes whatever it takes. Ok lets get this straight before I go on I am not jealous of Geelong. I hated geelong well before they started playing this great, free flowing and exciting brand of footy. However I am jealous that we are not playing that kin...

LENNY LEADS THE WAY wrote:poor delivery

flooded 50

the big man wasn't bad just didn't get a opportunity to shine

Thanks for that, its hard when you are only going on what they were saying on the radio and not being able to watch the game on telly.

Cheers battye, they made it sound bad on the radio, damn Triple M

It is interesting how people are talking about some of our other players and Fraser is not being spoken about at all. I didn't see the game as I don't have poxtel but to what I was hearing on the radio it does appear Fraser really did want to be out there playing tonight What's the go with him, just...

DSG...are we not allowed to congratulate our players after they play a good game? Xavier, Blake, Fiora, etc all can expect to get their praise after a good game...now, when they play shockers we are allowed to critise their game This is a football forum...and to false praise some of our players wou...

settle DSG! It's not like we are bagging Dal! What in gods name makes you think X is worth defending at the moment? So what he got the ball a few times. Big friggin deal. His disposal was barely amateur grade, definitely not even VFL level. His goal kicking (apart from the gimmie) was deplorable, a...

Seaford_Saint wrote:DSG.... don't you have a kid to go and feed???

go and talk a LONG walk of a short pier..... she is asleep not that its any of your bloody business

careful - don't bag him - people around here will get all depressed - apparently he 'tried hard'.... that's all that matters doesn't it??? FFS some of you people on here - face up to reality, or go support your local team, where 'trying' is great, as long as everyone is having fun. :roll: :roll: :r...

So X is the new whipping boy? Have fun, ya bunch of savages :roll: Yes it does appear that way, how quickly people forget about the good games, the poor bugger has had injuries over the past couple of years and appears to be struggling to find his feet. But hey we have our supporters sounding like ...

saintgus wrote:he is an absolute dud

HE DOES PLAY FOR ST KILDA, or have you forgotten
ah that's right he is now the new whipping boy

he is not alone, at least he gets the ball unlike the most disinterested player in Fraser who may as well retire now and stop wasting everyone's time.

Giddy up 4 touches,
last week just the one mark.

He is just Breaking records with them stats and people want to complain about X ....

I wouldn't, after watching that interview I wouldn't think he has ever used drugs, it didn't look like a man who was lieing.
He look like a man that is hurting alot from what has happened in the past week.

I feel for the poor guy..

only time will tell if this was the right move by the club...
'

jed wrote:Spida, Round 1 1993

Correct Jed.......

Your go mate!

riccardo wrote:It was Alan Murray, (who was kickless on debut for Port) vs Hawthorn in 2004.

That is incorrect ric.... I have rephrase my question to the next player..

There was a player before that.

We all know that Tony Lockett's first kick at VFL/AFL level resulted in a goal round 4, 1983 and then Stewart Loewe scored 2 goals with his first two kicks.

Question: Who was the next St Kilda after Lockett and loewe to kick a goal with there first kick in VFL/AFL Footy and when was it?

1978 George Young
Round 12 against Fitzroy
Kicked 10 goals straight

St Kilda played home games in Prahan and after the war Fitzroy were the other team to play at junction oval, as they moved from Brunswick St

I believe South Melb were playing at lake side

hard, very hard... with the G-train at full steam..

But Dal wins out for me

This is a no-brainer - Hamill is by far the best choice .... Thursday night should have proven that

i could not have said it better myself