I thought McGovern was on him, or was he loose man because I swear he was everywhere. Eagles would have been toast without him.

Earnt his spot, probably keeps wright out.

I want to defend billings but nothing he does is standing out that we don't get from others. A lot of standing around the edges with arms out waiting for it to fall in his hands. Had 1 or 2 truly damaging kicks tonight but his skills are meant to be his strength, don't know if it's enough.

Thought he played well, if we stop bloody kicking it to him on a half volley then he'd have the chance to keep the ball moving quicker. Was often outnumbered in packs but brought the ball down. So many saying he's unfit yet he still 1-2 meters ahead on a lead but we can't hit s*** with kicks.

Guarantee our club won't say s*** about the inconsistencies, just say the same thing every time it happens.

I'm f****** done with this s***. Every season, this should be an enjoyable game to watch but it's just makes me more and more pissed off. Absolutely disgusting.

Been a while since we would see a player go for a decent trot on the wing from half back regularly, maybe not since peake? One of the review shows had a break down of dogs/pies, essentially it was that initial run or short pass to get close to the zone and then just smash it over the top. Something ...

Good team, really happy with it!! Where has this Lonie negativity come from?? I can't believe it! He had 15 posi's and kicked 1:1. That nearly twice the no pf posi's that wright got!! Lonie is a ripper, a real team man and I think he'll be our small forward for our next premiership tilt! Plus he do...

West coast 58

So Barrett says it's something going on at the club yet roo hadn't heard about it till the show. He might not be captain anymore but I'm sure he could pick up on something not being right. Strange.

Please, please Richo - enough with the word "positive" There are plenty of other synonyms out there to use: A-grade, absolute, adept, admirable, awesome, badarse, bang-on, best, brilliant, collosal, cracker-jack, dynamite, excellent, exceptional, fantastic, fine, first-class, first-rate, ...

Armitage is never coming out, if he played every game last year getting injections for pain then there is no chance he's coming out after round 1. Out Roo Lonie Gilbert Wright Savage (if joey up) In Acres Paddy (if not managing minutes) Dempster Sinclair Joey Dempster-Gilbert swap as they are testin...

Billings was very good until half time and then was left wasted up forward. Great goal if Bomg kicked that there'd be a twelve line run down in the paper about it. It annoys me our club never gets recognition, I think it hurts our supporter base growth. Even greshams goal couldn't even make it to t...

Would these 2 get a game with another side? -Gilbo -Acres (pick one only...I pick Acres every day of the week) Easily acres and he averaged higher than gilbo last season who managed 15 disposals playing all 22 games. Fun fact: Acres played 6 less games in his first 2 seasons at this club than Jamie...

Yet our supporters love to rave about how good our recruiting team is. If you compare the number of top 10 picks between us and the dees you will see where the difference in recruiting comes from. We wouldn't even be considering finals at the start of the year if it wasnt for the value we have got ...

skeptic wrote:
Some get criticised too much, others not enough

We've been in a perpetual state of thinking armo will come back around ina couple weeks for over a season.

It's like we won't drop people when we know what they are capable of, and keep dropping people when we don't know what they are capable of.

Geez think some are still upset by the loss. He had 3 goals(1 brilliant, 1 sneaky crumb, 1 opportunistic mark). Set up a reiwoldt goal dancing round a defender. Set up Lonies goal dancing around a defender Think he had involvement in a couple more goals but can't remember how it all exactly went dow...

I'm gonna help your argument saints rising Freo won hitouts, didn't help freo with a tap ruckman of Sandilands caliber. 63-18. 42 point loss. NM won hit outs, didn't help with a tap ruckman of Goldsteins caliber. 51-29. 43 point loss. Pies won hitouts. 50-25. Lost by 14 points. Gws won hit outs 43-3...

Griggsy wrote:

Playon wrote:

WellardSaint wrote:

Griggsy wrote:30

OK, who will win then?

Beat me to it, Griggsy I cant take that tip, please read the rules. Be clear on who you're tipping

Only one option, saints by 30 of of course

Demons by 30....Can I change my mind, I now see why this was an issue

Minch is miles better than Lonie. What is it with Lonie? The choir boy hair-cut? So what if he tries like Scrappy do. He is very slow, gets caught a heck of a lot and most of his tackles are easily broken. Every now and then he lays a tackle because he sneaks up and noon sees him coming cos he is s...

Can anyone imagine Martin being as putrid as most of our team was after the first Qr ? yesterday ? I can't I cant either, i also can't see the rest of our team playing so poorly around Martin either. He is one of those guys who gets others involved more, if he wasn't then richmond would be up s*** ...

Yesterday, Hickey copped a hiding of epic proportions They controlled the Centre Sauare because Gawn did! Will be dropped I reckon No bounces due to the turf provided a "fair" contest which is a sure way that the better ruckman will always win. atleast with bounces it will favour one side...

I think this is a hysterical response to be honest... A guy ran around in the midfield unchecked whilst his team dominated... remind me, how great was he in the first quarter And Paddy written off after missing the game. Ppl need to get a grip Nobody is writing off Paddy. No, you only said he will ...

Yet our supporters love to rave about how good our recruiting team is. If you compare the number of top 10 picks between us and the dees you will see where the difference in recruiting comes from. We wouldn't even be considering finals at the start of the year if it wasnt for the value we have got ...

Perhaps messaging mods with your suspicion instead heading a witch hunt to divide the forum would have been better. As long as there is someone to hate, right.