Did chips take a late draft pick gee this is confusing, if they elevate Willkie does that mean we have 3 picks then use 2 and what of the other one is that for another they have identified who is delisted. And can they or will they relist parker, or savage, Marsh and if so would they be on the list ...

I hear clubs can now redraft 2 delisted free agents to the rookie list and that has now been extended to 6 so what does all this mean can we redraft Savage and parker Plus with OSCAR and Joyce on rookie list we are very small down back that is including Willkie only 191cm we will struggle against 20...

So our last 2 big defenders off the main list that makes us very venerable down back gee I hope they draft someone like Oscar Mcdonald at least he has some experience and only 23

We really need a Ruck forward or Back and he sounds good. But what if the best player is a 180 cm mid do we draft him instead that is what gags has indicated best player left not what we need. Plus young heath is around the 40 range our first pick is around late 20s. We desperately need young bigs w...

I have a real concern with the lack of quality talls we have especially down back as teams are getting bigger most KPF are now 200cm we only have 2 players of the size down back if 1 or both get injured we are in big trouble. Look at last season against Brisbane, Westcoast even bulldogs with Tim Eng...

We do need a big KPB Willkie, and Battle are great but only 191cm and 193 cm what happens when they come up against teams with 2 guys around 200 cm we struggled late in the season when Carlisle was not there roberton is only 194cm so either we play Oscar and now to get some experience ,or we look at...

Can we put Oscar and Phillips on rookie list and delist McKenzie Connolly Joyce we need players who are big to play CHB and CHF Willkie is good but not big enough if we put 2 on rookie list still leaves a spot there. I know paying out the contracts is expensive but those players are not going to pla...

Thanks for info to reduce the list can we delists contracted players as well.
I am worried Oscar clavinaro will get delisted or can they put him on rookie list?

Not keen on getting in another 30s player in. We do need help down back if Jake or Dougal go down. But I do really think if Oscar is the man they would have played him when Jake missed those games, on all accounts he was playing well in the trial games. But so was Matt parker and where is he now !! ...

Here are a few players we could go after. Sam Skinner he got cut from the Lions he is 198cm 23 years old played 3 games. He is a ruck /forward as he got cut like McKernan why not offer a 1 year deal as well right age and big enough could be a prospect. Or we could get Josh Schache he is out of contr...

I also think Ben King is our target but to get Ratugolea in would be a massive up side and i would play in Defence with Dougal as we are a bit small down back and struggled against some big strong forwards.

fine if they won't Hind we should ask picks 7,8 and a first and second round next year. Sounds like something Essendon would ask for ha. I would trade him for a first round pick and maybe a second or third play hard ball with them, depends how bad they need the pace, I would say we are in the box se...

What are they thinking why do we need another 30 something player we don't need old players when there are options out there. I am sure there are better players who are younger then him. Here are some options i was thinking of I am sure there are others. Oscar McDonald (Melbourne) 196cm 24 years old...

is it Ben King to the saints???????

What about Ratugolea now that Geelong is getting Cameron Ratugolea playing time will be reduced he would be a good fit age at 22 197cm

My reason for keeping Lonie is he is a goal kicker and they are hard to come by especially when you play as a small forward I know we have butler but he generally plays a bit different role. Lonie does not have that much pace but we have enough players that do, he gives forward pressure and he score...

I think we should try and get ben asap when he is out of contract GC have less of hold on him and they have a few big guys there i do think we will need to offer a player they are very young maybe a hind with experience and speed or a Sinclair or even a Carlisle they would really benefit with one or...

I see Sam skinner of Brisbane has been delisted he played us not bad KPP 198cm 23 years old only 3 games but hard to break into the there line up he could play as a key forward or back very handy and being delisted will be cheap.

how about his brother Oscar he is 24 as well we are great at making deals with clubs would be a good fit.

well some very good suggestions i like the McDonald one he has been there before and would be great back battle could be anything and it does allow us to be flexible where we play battle. We still need a ruckman I don't think McKernan is the answer Brisbane might be an idea as they do have a lot of ...

They have to be joking right there is a player at bulldogs josh schache who is out of contract 23 years old 199cm played about 50 odd games can play ruck, forward, and most of all where we should play him BACK with Dougal and trade Carlisle who will be 30 next year he has to be better then McKernan.

what about a josh schache as a key back he is only 23 199cm and the bulldogs don't play him could be handy can play forward or ruck as well.

I think we should go after a player like josh Schache from bulldogs I know he hasn't played much but he is 23 199cm 94kg 56 games can play forward and back he would be great as a replacement for Carlile who is 30 next season if he even stays with us. If the bulldogs wont a small from us like a hind ...

He should be a priority but to get a player like Caldwell who would be a 10 year player we might have to trade players like Hind, Sinclair, Savage, Dunstan, Roberton even dean Kent to other teams for draft picks to help our hand. I would not trade Paton or Phillips we need young guys carnt have all ...

Would love to get Crouch but Caldwell could be a 10 year player. I am a bit concerned about all the mature age recruits we need some quality younger guys its always come back to bite club that don't invest in youth as well as mature age. I understand our Pick situation but we should trade Dustan he ...