Hey Goodie. Check the timeline. That's what I said many posts ago.

Dear Savatage,

Love the numbered points. it does make you sound very authoritative. Funny i thought draft picks were all about making choices. The source of this was someone who was in a position to know. You, like many other so called experts on this site are not. Keep up the good work.

Despite what has been written here by all of the naysayers. Judd was willing to come to St Kilda. We chose not to take him.

What I have written is what I was told. The deal could have done to get Judd. We didn't get him Carlton did. The decision was made to get Armitage instead. Maybe they thought he would be a better player. Unfortunately I was not told the name of the genius in the football department responsible for t...

Let's hope whoever we get in the upcoming draft and the two smaller players recruited recently can make 2012 our year. 45 years is a long time to wait for a second premiership.

I couldn't care less if no-one believes this. I didn't post it to get mass approval. I did it because when I was told, i was so enraged that the so called St Kilda brains trust would pass up an opportunity to get a player of the calibre of Judd in a St Kilda jumper. It is blindingly obvious he would...

I couldn't care less if no-one believes this. I didn't post it to get mass approval. I did it because when I was told, i was so enraged that the so called St Kilda brains trust would pass up an opportunity to get a player of the calibre of Judd in a St Kilda jumper. It is blindingly obvious he would...

I should add I have no idea what was offered or not offered. Money or draft picks - wouldn't have a clue. But then again neither do the so called authorities on draft picks posting here which again I find very amusing.

There you go again. Second guessing what Chris Judd was thinking. My information says we could have done the deal and got Judd but instead we opted for Armitage. Now you can waste a lot of post space (which many of you are happy to do) blowing hot air about what you think were the facts and please f...

To my good friends Sax and Saintnick 12. You seem to know so much about what Judd was thinking he must be a close mate. So the next time you are invited around to his place for a BBQ, why don't you ask him?

I love reading this blog because you speak with such authority yet all you seem to blow is hot air. You have no idea what deals are done or in this case not done behind closed doors. I will freely admit most of the time I don't either. But on this occasion I happen to know what happened. My source (...

With a player of Judd's quality you would find a way. In any case that with the greatest respect is NOT the issue. The point I am making is that St Kilda chose Armitage over Judd.

It's not funny. It's a tragedy.

Armitage came to St Kilda in 2006. Judd went to Carlton in 2007. You do the maths.

He went to Carlton in 2007. But I do love the sarcasm.

It's interesting to note that the powers that be at St Kilda talk about re-building the club. I heard from an impeccable source that some years ago St Kilda could have recruited Chris Judd. Yes you heard right. But instead opted for David Armitage. An interesting choice to say the least. I venture t...