How about Neeld's pre-match speech to his players, televised on Ch 7? That is part of the problem at Demonland right there! I think it was meant to be inspiring. I found it to be totally unconvincing, and in fact quite embarrassing. Why take Natanui when you can pick Jack Watts? Why take Watters whe...

Maister was ok. He is ok. But that is all he will ever be - OK.

He is a 6/10 player. Not much variation week to week. He ranges beteen 5.5-6.5/10.

Kosi ranges between 2/10 and 7/10.

I think we need to take a punt on Lee.

I think we were not to far off the tigers Can't get over the fact GC beat us We should/could have been in a better spot 6 day break & travelling in from the tropics vs the Tiges off 9 day break and full of beans after beating the Blues in ROund 1. I thought we'd go down by 10 goals. Yet lost by...

5 Richmond goals from free kicks

is there anyone who still thinks that this guy doesn't belong?

Tiges off a 9 day break and getting up in a close one. Us, 6 day break, travel, going down in a close one. All adds up to a 10 goal loss I am afraid.

the away jumper is a major improvement; in fact it looks more 'St Kilda' than the home jumper now. The white stripe on Home jumper as others have mentioned is too narrow...

AFL site states AFL player arrested for stalking....

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/ ... fault.aspx

Beau Dowler is a tad taller I think and already has the extra bulk. Has just finished a season playing FB for Sandy. PLayed pretty well I believe. Previoulsy taken as top 10 draft pick by Pelchen for Hawthorn and then he brought him our way. Perhaps that is a plan B or C?

Trade Week Update from saints.com.au 9.10.12 12:56pm ST KILDA Head of Football Chris Pelchen has confirmed the Club is in discussions with West Coast in a bid to reach a deal that could see young forward Jamie Cripps trade places with Eagle’s defender Mitch Brown. Pelchen told SEN on Tuesday morning...

I think Blakey's days are over. I reckon there is a chance we will rookie list Beau Dowler as backup

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/149123/default.aspx Clayton said the Suns had spoken to most Victorian-based clubs over the future of Josh Caddy, who has said he wants to return to Victoria, and while a deal was a long way off, market demand for the young midfielder was posit...

great servant of the St Kilda Football Club. He fell into our laps in the first place and may be the gift that keeps on giving if Caddy works out. This is probably going to be a win-win deal for both parties. I wish him all the best although hope he plays no more than 99 games for the Bombers.

Greg Denham said this morning on SEN that Caddy seems headed for one of Geelong or Carlton.

Sam Fisher at 50 something in the draft. Siposs at 70 odd. You win some, you lose some.

3rd generation saint wrote:It's going to be interesting to see who is the sub, Ross or Ledger.

Doesn't the sub have to come from one of the 4 named on the bench? i.e Dal, Joey, Gears, Jack?

He has been good st Sandy this yr. I reckon it is very likely we will pick him up as a backup in the key back position, perhaps mature age rookie listed.

Riewoldt
Dal
Dempster
Milne
Simpkin

a real diversity of opinion across the forums on Raph tonight. Have seen some say it was his best game for quite a while! I reckon no one who was actually AT the game tonight would have been applauding Raph's game. His courage is undoubted, but his skills, decision making and execution are generally...

Little Dozer wrote:Gram's first quarter tonight is the perfect example why these sorts of discussions occur. How weakly did he approach at least 3 contests? Infuriating!!

Yes, spot on. I officially withdraw my support for Grammy. Time to go.

5. Steven
4. Armo
3. Blakey
2. Simpkin
1. Saad

5. Ray
4. Jones
3. Steven
2. Armo
1. Blake

Siposs showed his class with a searing left foot pass out of congestion on to the chest of someone on half forward, sometime in the 2nd quarter that directly led to a goal. He had another moment in the 4th qtr, so to say he showed "absolutely nothing" is wrong. Overall he did have a poor g...

Ross isn't going to recognise the backline Guys playing in front of their man, marking the ball, playing on.... I mean Seany for example, a career high 23 disposals. He'll be in a state of shock if Scotty keeps up that kind of directive with the defenders :) What a laugh.......Seany!!!!!! I assume ...

5. Hayes
4. Geary
3. Simpkin
2. Armitage
1. Stanley