Killa wrote: ↑Tue 14 May 2024 2:49pm And, no doubt, both Adelaide Clubs were in contact with his Agent

Or his Agent in contact with the Adelaide Clubs saying he is gettable

These are the facts

You have a strange definition of "fact"...Unless you have evidence that can prove your hypothesis.

Never spend 10% of your cap on any player Unless they are a consistent match winner in their prime Weitering is a full back He is worth 900k max David King went off at Melbourne when they went all-in on May and Lever...He lamented that you don't invest big on key defenders. Well he ate his words. I...

Should all players come back through the VFL after a lay off for whatever reasons no matter who they are ? Yes they can be competitive beasts but looking at some wheres the drive ….hey i’m earning 800,000 a year and they put me straight in….then does fa The short answer is "no"...The long...

Caminiti still has some defensive aspects to his game that requires significant work.

He is an UFA at the end of next year when he'll be 28. Carlton are not going to let him go when they're contending. And we shouldn't be chasing him if it's going to cost us high draft picks. So he’s a RFA this offseason, therefore if he accepts an off Carlton can match it or take the compensation p...

He is an UFA at the end of next year when he'll be 28.
Carlton are not going to let him go when they're contending.
And we shouldn't be chasing him if it's going to cost us high draft picks.

Killa wrote: ↑Tue 14 May 2024 2:34pm Or have the opposition improved?

There is an opposition you know, don’t you?

Possibly, but the opposition isn't responsible for unforced turnovers or missed set shots.
It also isn't responsible for our work rate reflected in the tackle count.

Got more chance of winning 1st division in the lotto than us making they 8 this season. Those are the facts. We are well short on talent and way off the pace. We over achieved last season. It's about rebuilding over the next few years so buckle up. That's not fact (not yet anyway) ... that's your o...

Ya reckon we have a chance? Sports bet do Saints $1.77 Freo $2.10 Obviously influenced by where game played (State) Those are outrageous odds. On what planet with what exposed form, do we warrant being $1.70 favourites. $2.10 for Freo is money for old rope. I'm not a gambler, but if I were, that is...

Why do they keep fumbling the ball? It’s so bad that every time they get they ball, I wince and expect someone to just stuff up. It’s a sign of lack of confidence and trust in your teammates. Because someone, somewhere will fumble, or they're expecting a poorly executed kick or handball. One missed...

So, someone that works for a player management company tweeted - on his own account - an observation about a team that he has no idea on the inner workings of? He isn't Phillipou's agent. Nor does he have anything to do with the St Kilda Football Club...It's also not clear how close to Phillipou he...

Found it interesting, being able to hear the players clearly, that Jones was yelling at Caminiti to pick up his defender. Caminiti presented well in the forward line and was a clear target, but he clearly still has defensive areas that he needs to address. Until those issues are resolved and while h...

So, someone that works for a player management company tweeted - on his own account - an observation about a team that he has no idea on the inner workings of? He isn't Phillipou's agent. Nor does he have anything to do with the St Kilda Football Club...It's also not clear how close to Phillipou he ...

I'll be there...
Staying with the in-laws just up the road from the oval tonight...

So teasing your POV out a little further, is it possible, or has it happened before where Kevin Sheehan writes up a draft prospect such as Pou that has not met the profile projected in his write up at AFL level? If the answer is yes, then what is it you have seen in his 30 AFL games that makes you ...

B.M wrote: ↑Fri 10 May 2024 4:32pm Would you be ok for a permanent name change?

No. We are the St Kilda Football Club...
But I don't have the issue with the name change for the SDNR.

I wonder if other clubs are having these discussions? Imagine the chardonnay and cheese platter brigade at Naarm. What outrage.

Can you direct me to the links where Sheehan is critical of a junior player potentially getting drafted? ….. Sure... https://www.afl.com.au/news/sheehan Are you seriously questioning the credibility of Sheehan? Not at all. His role is to help these kids get drafted. Just like a Real Estate agents j...

Moods wrote: ↑Fri 10 May 2024 4:26pm Can you direct me to the links where Sheehan is critical of a junior player potentially getting drafted? …..

Sure...
https://www.afl.com.au/news/sheehan

Are you seriously questioning the credibility of Sheehan?

Be mindfull of the fact that the marketeers who write the draft bios also write the blurbs for wine labels. Without being disrespectful, I'd trust Kevin Sheehan's words over yours anyday. Would have forgotten more about junior talent than all of us on this site would know. Mattaes Phillipou State: ...

Perhaps tell a story in dance with commentary or text across our screens which highlight an advanced society that survived and thrived with 100's of clans and 100's of languages and skills and bush medicine...etc What if there was a demonstration of farming methods that date back 20,000 years. What...

Yep Really does a lot of good for our people Makes up for everything and fixes many of the issues in our communities Does every gesture have to benefit someone? Is the role of the AFL or the St Kilda Football Club to come up with a solution to fix issues in our communities? Everything is about slow...

As an Australian with aboriginal heritage A lot of this tokenism actually annoys me A lot White people wanting to make themselves feel good As an Australian with Indigenous heritage, I don't see this as tokenism. This is a nod to the oldest living culture on the planet. It does no harm at all and r...

Geez...Some of these posts are like reading the comments section of the Melbourne remedial newspaper, the Herald-Sun...Or an Andrew Bolt editorial.

Brunswicksainter wrote: ↑Thu 09 May 2024 3:10pm

Life Long Saint wrote: ↑Thu 09 May 2024 3:00pm

Brunswicksainter wrote: ↑Thu 09 May 2024 2:40pm Bit of Hyperbole champion. Genuinely disliked*

Condescending, much?

Apologies muscles.

Brunswicksainter wrote: ↑Thu 09 May 2024 2:40pm Bit of Hyperbole champion. Genuinely disliked*

Condescending, much?