Are we fit now?
If not why??

We made the top 8 last year because every other side around us, had a spectacular fall In other words...We did a Bradbury Essendon, The Bulldogs, Geelong and Fremantle were all better than us and had games where they lost to sides they should have easily beaten. Even Richmond were fighting for a sp...

I don't agree. They're just as biased as anyone else.

B.M wrote: ↑Mon 27 May 2024 10:04pm How big do they have to be?

At least 195.

Caminiti needs to practise his kicking. It needs a lot of work. He can't kick a goal unless he's in the goal square and straight in front. No point playing in the forward line if you can't kick a goal with the 2 chances you get. Useless in the ruck so what's his worth?

B.M wrote: ↑Mon 27 May 2024 9:43pmJosh Battle?!

Not big enough.

Any CHBs who can mark the ball?

Yep, Bassat and Lyon should stay the 4 years and see this out. St Kilda are the worst at sackings. For once in their lives that should stick to the plan.

You are right. Collard was running around like a headless chicken. At the moment he's not up to it. He should play at Sandy for the rest of the year.

St Lenny wrote: ↑Mon 27 May 2024 10:54am

samuraisaint wrote: ↑Sun 26 May 2024 9:07pm Clark, Crouch, Jones, Membrey in next week.
Should also give Allison and/or Hotton a chance too.

Please not Jones, I never want to see him play for us again.

Same goes for Ross. He's cooked well done.

He's feeling down and out because he's playing with a goose in defence.

It should be his last game for St Kilda. He's more uncoordinated than a baby giraffe.

Worse than poor. He's shocking!

Nah Ross should drop Howard, Collard, Caminiti, Ross and Bonner. All terrible today.

Need to piss off Howard. Always falls over and gifts goals to opposition. He's horrible.

WellardSaint wrote: ↑Thu 23 May 2024 3:39pm Imagine if the fool (Jon Ralph) visits here as one of the hundreds of guests.
Or maybe he's Curly or BM or Vortex.

He's gonna get excited that he's atarted us arguing.
And he'll show his bosses

I'm sure he does.

G'day Jon you are a d**khead!

How the hell do you over achieve?

Maybe the cards fell their way but then they had lots of injuries. The dick would have been more correct by saying based on last year's results, this year, The Saints have under achieved. But Ralph isn't smart enough for that!

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/not-in ... aeb81807c2
“Ross absolutely buggered it up – not by his own doing, he massively overachieved last year,”
WTF?

sks023 wrote: ↑Mon 20 May 2024 5:31pm Harley can write his own ticket in Perth, and won't be going anywhere soon

Well he's pretty homesick. Said his birthday spent in Perth was the worst ever. They let him go home on the week off.

Rohan Colony should stick to following Essendon

Farken hell. Sack Lyon and replace him with who?
That's been St Kilda's story for the last 100 years and it's yet to work. In the eyes of Einstein this is the definition of insanity!

We're been rebuilding since 2010 and before that 97. Lindsay Fox had a 5 yr plan in the 80s. Is that still ongoing?

I think it's ok to respect the Indigenous name so yeah it's a good thing.

Like all Saints supporters we are sick of this s***.

What did Philipou do at Sandy that warranted selection?
He was horrible. Steele played a shocker, Jones hardly touched it, King tried. It seems to me that Lyon hasn't got the game plan to get the best out of this group.