Under-rated by many supporters, a great servant of the club.

I think it is the right decision. Interesting to see if he is picked up by another club.

Five Freo players, most of any team and they didn't make the final 8!!!

Maybe some WA bias.

I read somewhere Membrey has been offered 3 years by another club.

If this is true he is likely to go.

Sinclair clearly Best for Saints and BOG according to at least one radio station. Probably the only player on the ground to make something of all of his (28) possessions. Very even performance from several other Saints players. Scollop once again couldn't find a place for Sinclair in his top 6 play...

5 Sinclair 2 Jones 2 Pou 1 Clark 1 Wilson 1 Steele 1 NWM 1 Marshall 1 Byrnes Sinclair clearly Best for Saints and BOG according to at least one radio station. Probably the only player on the ground to make something of all of his (28) possessions. Very even performance from several other Saints play...

chook23 wrote: ↑Fri 23 Aug 2024 3:16pm

chook23 wrote: ↑Fri 23 Aug 2024 3:16pm

StPeter wrote: ↑Fri 23 Aug 2024 3:03pm Curnow is out for Carlton.

Maybe will change who Saints select

Howard
Wilkie
Battle

Match ups???

Maybe Battle goes forward

Curnow is out for Carlton.

Maybe will change who Saints select

4 Wilkie
3 Wilson
2 Steele
2 Marshall
2 Sinclair
1 Clark
1 Jones

SaintPav wrote: ↑Sun 18 Aug 2024 7:02pm Meaningless win according to Damien Barrett.

Ignorant twat.

If we won the premiership Barrett would find a way to hose it down. He has never had any respect for St Kilda.

Excellent summary of the situation.
At the time we traded Acres, as you say the stake knives, along with 2 first round draft picks, I said it is the worst decision of many shockers by the Saints over many years. He always looked to me that he would develop into something special.

Scores level at half time. Garcia looking so good.

I wonder if he will be rested before the match finishes as he played for more than a quarter yesterday.

A huge influence in his limited game time tonight.

Hopefully gets a full game next week.

I think Lyon is a fan of Byrnes, more than many on this forum.
He was promoted again on below-average form with Sandy but he has proved that he has something to offer at AFL level.
I think he is definitely worth keeping.

Yes please

Marshall Battle Clark Dow Skunk Scollop are you sure you recovered from your earlier post about having a couple (and I suggest more than a couple)? The only person to omit Sinclair including both coaches who gave him votes. His performance and stats and influence on the game I think put him well ah...

Marshall Battle Clark Dow Skunk Scollop are you sure you recovered from your earlier post about having a couple (and I suggest more than a couple)? The only person to omit Sinclair including both coaches who gave him votes. His performance and stats and influence on the game I think put him well ah...

9 Daniel Rioli (RICH)
7 Rowan Marshall (STK)
7 Josh Battle (STK)
4 Jack Sinclair (STK)
3 Callum Wilkie (STK)

Interesting that both coaches chose the same 5 players although different scores for each.

Rioli 5/4
Marshall 4/3 or 5/2
Battle 4/3 or 5/2
Sinclair 3/1
Wilkie 2/1

5 Marshall
3 Battle
3 Sinclair
2 Wilkie
1 Membrey
1 Dow

Every week we give up red time goals!!!!!!

5 Sinclair
3 Pou
3 Battle
2 NAS
1 Steele
1 Marshall

It seems Billings and Gresham have both been failures at their new clubs backing Saints decision to let them go,

All three are/were first class defenders but I would have Cal in front of Max for the reasons others have stated.

Unfortunately Penny's career cut short so we don't have the same body of work on which to judge him fairly.

Waltzing St Kilda wrote: ↑Tue 30 Jul 2024 7:28pm Garcia's stats were pretty low.

I said starting 22.

Leigh Matthews, commentating on the radio when praising the Saints, pointed out that it is a rare stat for every one of the 22 players to get 10+ possessions like we did against Essendon on Saturday. However it was the second week in a row for us. The starting 22 players all gained 10+ possessions a...

Sincs slow start to the year because of his calf injury will affect his chances.

The way the scoring system works, the good players that play all games have a definite advantage.