I guess Lockett's 69% is close enough for you. But you'd be disappointed in Milne for 59%. we should both be disgusted in Billings for 46%. Just once, you could do your own research before you post. It will help make me look like less of smart arse. :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen:...

I don’t have many heroes But Nick Reiwoldt is one Alongside Ponting, Harvey, Hayes For me, Ditterich, Muir and Cuz. Muir is a great choice. Well before my time but from everything I’ve seen and read… very under appreciated for his time with the addition of probably would have been an all time once ...

I don’t have many heroes But Nick Reiwoldt is one Alongside Ponting, Harvey, Hayes For me, Ditterich, Muir and Cuz. Three of the biggest hot heads we have ever had... :roll: :roll: :roll: :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :shock: :shock: :shock: :lol: :lol: :lol: So??????? Plus you makes 4 hot heads. :...

saynta wrote: ↑Sun 31 Dec 2023 5:40pm 2024....I've got a feeling....Happy New Year guys and gals.

I have had the same feeling since three quarter time in the 1971 Grand Final...

saynta wrote: ↑Sun 07 Jan 2024 10:35am They were hopeless in this last test.

saynta wrote: ↑Sun 07 Jan 2024 10:42am

B.M wrote: ↑Tue 02 Jan 2024 8:14pm I don’t have many heroes

But Nick Reiwoldt is one

Alongside Ponting, Harvey, Hayes

For me, Ditterich, Muir and Cuz.

Three of the biggest hot heads we have ever had...

I don't want to shoot Bambi but I believe Membrey should only play if we have injuries.
Give the responsibility to the young guys...

Steele and crouch will have better seasons I'd say Steele could challenge Sincs if he remains injury free in 2024. I think Crouch may have already plateaued. We all know you can't compare their output for 2023 when Crouch played every game last year and had more of a chance to gain and maintain his...

CQ SAINT wrote: ↑Sat 06 Jan 2024 4:10am Dads already said Boston will be a Saint if picked..

He is in Melbourne already.

From what I have heard he is not good enough but we might rookie him...

I00s of players have been the same height or taller than Nick Riewoldt. But he’s not as fit, not as strong , not as good a leader etc Rooey was exceptional. Coops also doesn’t play like Nick Riewoldt. Their styles are completely different. So I don’t get the point of bringing up his height. The dis...

With 36 goals - he’s not a 2gpg small forward Butler kicked 33 goals - and actually defended Higgins only played 22 games in 2023 out of a possible 24 and kicked 36 goals. He has been improving every year he has been at the Saints. Give him a clean bill of health in 2024 and he just might kick 50 g...

I00s of players have been the same height or taller than Nick Riewoldt. But he’s not as fit, not as strong , not as good a leader etc Rooey was exceptional. Coops also doesn’t play like Nick Riewoldt. Their styles are completely different. So I don’t get the point of bringing up his height. The dis...

B.M wrote: ↑Fri 05 Jan 2024 3:18pm Not sure what position he is suited to

He is not a key forward - undersized

He is not a hybrid - not good enough at ground level

I think his best chance is to add 5-8kg

He is exactly the same height as N. Riewoldt.

From today's Hun, not to be read by anyone who disparages the Murdoch press :lol: " ST KILDA TO KICK ON by Jay Clark They have already been dubbed likely sliders in 2024. The popular theory is St Kilda caught the opposition off guard in 2023 by making finals but are set to come back to the pac...

WTF?

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 04 Jan 2024 11:36pm Nope

Don’t agree

If he was a better kick, and better defensively maybe

I think Butler is a better small forward

I'm not sure how you can disagree that he was our leading goal kicker.

B.M wrote: ↑Fri 05 Jan 2024 12:02am History tells us

You need at least half a dozen A Grade players to contend

You do not make it to the top 4 otherwise

False, you need a great team that are well coached.

Good riddance?! Come on man, that’s fkn disrespectful to a 10 year servant Who played 155 games He will be a life member of StK And what did he do, other than what the coach wanted and leave As I said, like Ball, papers were stamped, Ross rightly or wrongly forms certain opinions on players and tha...

He’s not in the best 10 players at stk Nor should a forward pocket be Sinclair Marshall Steele King Wilkie Crouch Owens Wanganeen Milera Hill Would be my best 10 Outside of that Wood Membrey Ross Clark Webster Higgins Butler Battle Henry Howard Fringe Windhager Dow Stocker Byrnes Sharman Not sure h...

This is the most interesting part to me- albeit only based on output last year. Defenders: Top 10: 2, 11-30: 3, 31-50: 1 Midfielders: Top 10: 2, 11-30: 1, 31-50: 3 Forwards: Top 10: 1, 11-30: 1, 31-50: 3 It's not surprising reading but you can see why we have prioritised midfielders in Dow and Henr...

Seriously doubt Sharman will ever be the 'Greatest of all time', but I'd be delighted if he became a GAP (good average player) and finished top 10 in our B&F. He definitely will. He is a natural footballer. I can see him being top 3 in our best & fairest one day... Top 3 in the b&f != G...

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 04 Jan 2024 1:05pm Name a champion team that doesn’t have champions?

90s Bulls? Hang on???

We have very few match winning stars
Which is why we won’t be a contender

I didn't say a champion team doesn't have champion players in it.

Big Max wrote: ↑Thu 04 Jan 2024 8:30pm Seriously doubt Sharman will ever be the 'Greatest of all time', but I'd be delighted if he became a GAP (good average player) and finished top 10 in our B&F.

He definitely will. He is a natural footballer. I can see him being top 3 in our best & fairest one day...

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 04 Jan 2024 3:16pm Think you mean Doosra

Offies don’t bowl wrong ones…

As far as I know, doosra is just another term for wrong one (wrong 'un).

He is the spin bowler for the Australian cricket Test team, otherwise know as Gary. Nah, he is hopeless. He can't bowl a wrong'un. :roll: You a cricket expert as well? I am actually. A long time ago I won the best & fairest as a pace bowler in Year 12 cricket however I also bowled leg spin. I h...