Yes we are tired and uninterested maybe just maybe we drop a few experienced players it wont happen but WE ARE GONE AGAIN!

Will we lose by over 50points to WC its really embarrassing.
WE were better last season again we crumble after the bye

I do like him. Has been a decent forward and could slot in next to King or as a utility defender. Pbly an upgrade on Cordy [/quo I have to disagree with you on the upgrade on cordy Zane has played over 100 games as a KD played as a key defensive unit in a premiership is very experienced and makes g...

same we we are losing to WC we are not dropping players who don't contribute week after week I mean experienced players or who need a rest selection integrity

get Owens in the midfield NOW! and how bad is Battle play him up forward at least then if he makes a mistake its not a goal!!!

Selection integrity has gone out the window the only way players get a game is if there is a injury. Dougal should stay in the team he does really well considering he is covering for Battle most of the time. Battle does some good things but when he makes a mistake and they are often he gives up a go...

Its very difficult with Dougal as Battle is a liability with his lack of speed, the really bad mistakes in giving away frees cost us goals and really poor decision making plus he is always at least 3-5 cm smaller then his opposition player (not his fault but other players of his height do well not h...

Is it time to play Cordy in his rightful position as a KPD with Dougal poor Dougal has been left to take a lot of the defensive work as Battle is struggling when the he has to chase or jump he is very restrictive. At least cordy has played over 100 as a KPD and working with Dougal it would be a grea...

I really think JB is gone by next season he is really struggling at CHB and now we have coverage in Cordy and some young guys coming through.

What big name recruit are out of contract for 24 that we can target we have to get another quality mid if not 2 and a KPF and a ready made Ruck to help Row.
I would also get a young Ruckman to come up through the system with Heath there are plenty around in draft and other leagues.

What big name recruit are out of contract for 24 that we can target we have to get another quality mid if not 2 and a KPF and a ready made Ruck to help Row.
I would also get a young Ruck to come up with Heath there are plenty around.

The only problem I see in trading Gresham is that we will not get a pick that worth him its better to keep him then get a late pick at least we know what we get with him .As for jones Offer a 1 or 2 year contract if he doesn't come up we cut or trade him. Butler is a must stay as we don't really hav...

Why when Saints have a bye Sandringham do as well I would have thought it would have been a great time for the coaches to get down to watch the boys and for players to impress with no Saints footy on. When are we getting a saints VFL team they would play out of Moorabbin and our alignment would be c...

skeptic wrote: ↑Fri 02 Jun 2023 9:38am I hope we take him in the mid season draft

Sorry that ship has sailed MSD was last night we had no picks.

I would not like to loose gresh or Clark but JB could be traded we need a pick

2 questions: How was Windhager defensively & who were our goal kickers? Windy was excellent. He was everywhere. Clearly to good for AFL level. Had a lovely 50m set shot. Max Heath was an early goal kicker but he faded out. Keeler was awesome. Did a lot of defensive tackling in our forward 50. I...

Is there a difference or do certain players get given more latitude than they genuinely deserve? Have some players credits run out? Injuries can only paper over so many cracks. Byrnes - I tried so hard not to see his limitations but he has too many. Hard to imagine we do not have better. Webster / ...

How about Father son 75 games a comprisme the AFL might like and it does mean it will be 4-5 years if no injury or form laps still a long time to serve in a club

Sometimes the saints keep a few emergency aside for the main game could they play in the VFL with the sub from the AFL side.
The VFL is at RESA park on Saturday night 5pm it would be good for all the Emergency's to play in that game as many haven't played for a while.

Hopefully Membrey is fit to return. Bytel got more of the ball in the VFL, but I believe Windhager would bring more to the AFL side. Out: Ross & Owens Ins: Membrey, Windhager Sub Paton. I watched the whole game. Bytel and Highmore were impressive. Windy, unfortunately for him, was not. I saw no...

I Hayes is not back for at least 10 weeks then he would not be ready to play AFL so he is out of contention this season. Having Owens as a pinch hitter ruck is very dangerous for the kid up against 200+ guys over 100kg it could shorten his career being pounded by these guys on a long term basic. He ...

I did here that Richmond is after Ken Hinkley would that mean that Port is interested in Hardwick or he might go to WC.
Don't think he would be interested in GC with no supports and not many at games its a big let down from the massive Richmond MCG games.

Yes we need another ready made Ruck someone who could come in case Row or Campbell goes down like last season that would be disastrous. Owens is not big enough and Hammer is not good enough to take a team through to the finals and heath is still very raw. Would be a shame if we made the finals and h...