5 Marshall
4 Steele
2 Hill
2 Nasiah
2 Battle

We don’t know and for a start, maybe Clarko may not even have gotten that team to finals, let alone GF. Some say we were already on a downer by the time RTB arrived. 2004 - Prelim Final 2005 - Prelim Final 2006- Elimination Final. Senior Leaders in Robert Harvey and Lenny Hayes and a wealth of tale...

So what was the big Collingwood turn around if not coaching and game plan? Not as simple as that They had drama in the board room and with the coach distracted from his duties in my opinion. There was some talk of Nathan Buckley retiring after 2020 and he wasn’t motivated to coach. Buckley split up...

Rest any player with niggles or any tightness. I’d be inclined to manage Pou this week Mattaes will get plenty of opportunity to play in big games for his career. They have Ratugolea, De Koning, and Stewart. We need to isolate these guys. No long bombs!! I know it won’t happen, but I’d love to see K...

We nearly buried Carlton. The St Kilda foot was lifted and about to be placed fair square onto their throat as we built a 3-4 goal lead late in the second quarter. We came out early in the third and after Max King’s second goal we retained a 22 point lead half way into the 3rd quarter. We were clean...

5. Steele
3. Windy
3. Roma
2. Owens
2. Wilkie

5 Holla
4 Man of Steel
3 Nas
2 Wilkie
1 . Webster

Owens stiff. Sinclair very good, Howard and Crouch and Mason Wood all good games. Windy should never be dropped again

Like Jim Kerr used to sing in the 80’s; ‘Don’t you forget about me’

I would have been a good match up for Petracca

Are they fit or not? Zak has played 2 now in the VFL Billings played 4 then missed 2 then played another 2 Bytel has been fkd around Too much pigeon holing for my liking?! I guess we will find out about Jones and Billings when the side is selected tomorrow night. I don't think it's at all surprisin...

Marshall
Owens
Sinclair
Wood
Howard

For those of you who haven’t included Ross in your votes, go back and have a look at the replay and see how he wins his possessions. His contested work was easily best on our side of the ledger, and was my best player closely followed by Sinclair - and daylight to the rest. Hill best of the rest , ...

5 Wood
4 Clark
3 Owens
2 Butler
1 Sinclair

Lyon has been there before. Therefore he’ll do it again. That’s the logic; right? Ratten had some success in finals AND with 2 different teams over his career so why couldn’t he do that again? Granted he didn’t go all the way, but he had success with THIS squad in recent times. Would have been a dif...

I’m sure Lyon will be able to extract the very best out of our talented and skilful list I hope/expect him to extract the very best, but I'm sure he'll extract more than his predecessor. And his predecessor's predecessor. And the one before that too. And ideally even the one before that. Spot on Wh...

Here’s my optimistic take Simon and Andrew want to turn St Kilda into a powerhouse Club. Some bloke said “Why not us” and they went with it! If they succeed in getting all the right structures in place for sustained success it will create a snowball effect that can help the club for many decades. He...

Need to know Syd's nickname: Is it Smoke? 'Arbor? Vicious? SS? Can tell a lot from the nic. Richmond called him surplus. If Syd’s a ladies man, maybe ‘James’ might be appropriate. What’dya fink? No good? Ok, Carry On https://www.bbc.co.uk/comedy/people/sid_james_person_page.shtml https://www.dailym...

Curious to know JB, would you have kept Ratten? It worked for Geelong when they kept Mark Thompson. It worked for Richmond when they kept Hardwick It also worked for Geelong again in 2018 when they kept Chris Scott It’s not like Brett had a career coaching record of 33%. His finals record for St Ki...

Tim Membrey has been the Saints leading goal kicker in 2016, 2017 and 2019. He’s a role model when it comes to training He is a beast of an athlete. He had to work hard to earn a spot to play his first game of AFL at Sydney Sydney already had Tippett, Goodes and Sam Ried and then in Tim’s second yea...

Curious to know JB, would you have kept Ratten? It worked for Geelong when they kept Mark Thompson. It worked for Richmond when they kept Hardwick It also worked for Geelong again in 2018 when they kept Chris Scott It’s not like Brett had a career coaching record of 33%. His finals record for St Ki...

I know that it’s super important for the players to unite and for the club to unite and move forward, but that doesn’t mean I have to be a sheep. I’ll continue to support the club and I hope Lyon Mk 2 is a different beast to the bloke who once stated he was a ‘career coach’ who didn’t feel the need ...

Personally I am convinced that our footy team will not go backwards in 2023 - quite the opposite, they only need to win 2 more games than they did in 2022 to secure a spot in the top 8, my money is on them doing exactly that! If the club is serious about winning a premiership and not just trying to...

Regardless not sure what those “hard hitting opinion pieces” prove The headline in the first article says it all ‘Chaos in the front office and a toxic culture at training: Why the Dockers had to sack Ross Lyon’ ….but what is equally as concerning as the toxic relationships between player and coach...

Personally I am convinced that our footy team will not go backwards in 2023 - quite the opposite, they only need to win 2 more games than they did in 2022 to secure a spot in the top 8, my money is on them doing exactly that! If the club is serious about winning a premiership and not just trying to...

Regardless not sure what those “hard hitting opinion pieces” prove The headline in the first article says it all ‘Chaos in the front office and a toxic culture at training: Why the Dockers had to sack Ross Lyon’ ….but what is equally as concerning as the toxic relationships between player and coach...

The criticism and the reports in the media are from those who were at the club and who knew people who worked at the club The pressure mounted at Freo in 2019 because their results didn’t live up to expectations The evidence is factual history not revisionist cliched history and it’s based on Lyon’...