So...which is it? Lyon was shithouse last year but the players were good enough OR Lyon was the reason last year But....in 2024 Lyon is shitzen or its the players? If its Lyon...PROVE how he has significantly altered the game plan from 23 to 24. Whats actually accurate is the lay the blame across t...

So...which is it? Lyon was shithouse last year but the players were good enough OR Lyon was the reason last year But....in 2024 Lyon is shitzen or its the players? If its Lyon...PROVE how he has significantly altered the game plan from 23 to 24. Whats actually accurate is the lay the blame across th...

Heath ( kicked 2.2, 7 marks and 23 disposals) ..both did alot of very good work. Moose could have kicked 4.0 - both his misses were easy enough to slot - not sure why he missed so badly to the left and then overcorrected to the right. I agree he was having plenty of it, bit rough to miss. I do unde...

Gone by 2026 - Crouch, Ross, Webster, Campbell, membrey, Wood, You can add Zak Jones to that list "os", maybe Dougal Howard who I expect will be surpassed by Arie Schoenmaker. Question marks also about Matthew Allison, Ryan Byrnes, Brad Hill (same age as Wood) and possibly Jack Hayes, Dan...

Agree wholeheartedly.

This is where we miss a few who we lost in 2024 and currently Higgins.

Nice win today...110pts lead was nice to watch Saw some encouraging play by St Kilda listed players. Crouch & Hunter & Hayes all looked good. Oddly hear commentators mention all the 'interest' in Benier. Didnt seem that good. Who was your favourite player today? Mine was tied between Garcia ...

But the players were ok last season?? Did ya watch any games after the half way mark of the season? Once we got back our 'seniors' from injury we began a slow decline to blah. Really after Caminiti was suspended we collapsed. Senior Coach Asst Coaches System Culture Players Injuries These factors a...

My thoughts are not a Kingy bashy sooky point of view. I really like Max. I reckon he is incredible. We desperately need him. What shitz me is that he HAS the ability, skills and talent. We have watched him play brilliantly. The excuses need to be weighed and given some merit...e.g. ball movement f...

My thoughts are not a Kingy bashy sooky point of view. I really like Max. I reckon he is incredible. We desperately need him. What shitz me is that he HAS the ability, skills and talent. We have watched him play brilliantly. The excuses need to be weighed and given some merit...e.g. ball movement f...

My thoughts are not a Kingy bashy sooky point of view. I really like Max. I reckon he is incredible. We desperately need him. What shitz me is that he HAS the ability, skills and talent. We have watched him play brilliantly. The excuses need to be weighed and given some merit...e.g. ball movement fr...

Ive refrained from calling Max a bust...however his gutless, passionless effort tonight was insipid.

But who cares? We cant drop him! We'd never survive without his 3 marks & 1 behind.

B.M wrote: ↑Tue 14 May 2024 7:26pm Max Benier got 3 possessions in the VFL Sunday

Good enuough, bring him in, we desperately need another 63 defenders lol

My nan kicked the bucket...twice...Max you are sh1te!

Geelong VFL ruckman Ajang Kuol Mun or Andrew Phillips? Mun is obviously the longer term value with seemingly a lot of upside but Phillips could offer a few years of back up that would strengthen ROMO's game, Phillips has more experience than Campbell but is he an add or subtract for us? We need a ru...

Maxwell Benier - what gives? Are we seriously looking at another defender in the mid season draft? WHY? WHY!!!

I haven't heard the line "this group is so coachable" at any time this year. What does that even mean? Talks in monologue/riddles at press conferences like some great guru. If you don't understand you must be stupid! Geez you’ve been waiting to get this shyte off the liver for a while ! G...

I also just find it soooo frustrating that we can’t develop and stick to a long term plan GT invests in youth, gets sacked after finishes of 4th, 4th and 6th - 5 years later RL runs the list into the ground developing no youth Saints go to Tassie then leave Tassie after a couple of years Commit to ...

I'm pretty sure we had a larger injury list at the start of 2023 than 2024. It was RTB, a new strategy, the vibe at the club, favourable schedule, etc etc. that contributed to our top 8 position. But we definitely snuck in as we rarely won games in the last half of the season ( even some games we 'w...

Some of you just don’t listen to the club and overlay your own agendas on top. Club has been very clear that we were “kidding ourselves” under Ratten and were further away than we thought. Ross was brought in to rebuild and we’ve maximized our draft hand in both drafts post Ratts. Club has been con...

We have needed KPP in every area for 10 years ( add years to suit personnel suffering), we've tried drafting, trades for impact, coach, board, staff changes, etc. There's some hope in 1-5yr players... But every area is in controlled shambles still. Our biggest crisis is the midfield & forward l...

Who are the two idiots? NFI but I'm guessing Battle given his FA status. Or has he re-signed? Typical of BM’s modus operandi of posting D.B.Cooper - he refuses to use the quote button so you often don’t know who he’s replying to in a thread. Now he’s obviously listened to or watched ‘2 idiots’ &...

No comparison to Roo at the same stage of his career. None at all. Definitely not.... 2001Nick waltzes into Harvard - Gehrig, Everitt, Loewe, Hall...with Hamill, Hayes, Harvey, Milne in the mid and small forwards....SUPPORT. ALL DAY EVERY GAME...for years. King crawls into Frankston TAFE and he's g...

No comparison to Roo at the same stage of his career. None at all. Definitely not.... 2001Nick waltzes into Harvard - Gehrig, Everitt, Loewe, Hall...with Hamill, Hayes, Harvey, Milne in the mid and small forwards....SUPPORT. ALL DAY EVERY GAME...for years. King crawls into Frankston TAFE and he's g...

People were talking about Max King in the same sentence as Coleman Medal before the season started. What has changed? He's still leading for the.... GARY COLEMAN Medal. King's "Whatchu talkin bout" when asked to play as an actual Key Forward has him easily leading for this prestigous awar...

I thought watching Sharman today he was ok. But not great. Hes consistent...meaning he gets a bit of the ball, gets a shot or two on goal...but nothing you cant live without. At times he's been in marking contests similar to Caminiti...can mark & bring ball to ground. Wouldnt think either player...