Waltzing St Kilda wrote:We were aggressive when he showed the door to McEvoy, Lynch, Dal Santo, Goddard and Stanley.
Not sure where that's got us.

Pelchen said McEvoy, BJ and Nick dal had to go in order to improve the list.
We have to turn over the list each year to find the right dynamic

elizabethr wrote:How could anyone gain please from this ?

Google 'schadenfreude' dear liz...

Richo being aggressive.? Ha.
The man's a weird bugger.

A lot of selections are puzzling.
Mav. Big ??? there.
Bringing in Long twice.
Not giving White a decent go.
Not letting Battle have another game.

Don't believe his spin.
He's a weird cat.

If you're worried about Koby, I think he's more than made up for Armo. He gets the ball a lot, competes well, tries to kick or hb to advantage, and we are lucky he's in the middle. I think he stays and he's valuable, not just as depth. Surround him with skill like Martin or Kelly, and watch him get ...

Mav- does an incredible job of blocking.

Minchington- has been in and out without showing consistent strong form.

Wow, this is very negative. Sure, he hasn't had a great season and has been on the fringe the whole time. But to bag him out like this, right at the end of the season is very harsh. Every footy coach in the damn world knows that you give players several chances and "turn the list over" by...

What an absolute spud of a player. Useless yet again. Not that I'm surprised. Should be delisted tomorrow, but instead will be contracted until 2019. Yes Four times if he was able to pick the loose ball up he could of had a running shot at goal . Instead he fumbled. Not good enough in the big leagu...

If St Kilda had scored only 3 more points we would have finished 10th on the ladder instead of 11th. That would have cost us draft pick 8 (1551 draft points) down to draft pick 9 (1469 draft points) Those draft points being before AFL adjustments due to free agency compensations and the impact of q...

What is the purpose of Lonie and Weller? Genuine question. Mav provides two essential things 1-....Blocking 2-....there is a lady supporter who has 51 years continuous membership who is Mav's Sponsor she has a photo on twitter standing with Mr "10 kgs of potatoes in a 5 kg bag" Is it a ju...

Sainternist wrote:I attended the match today with the old Jiggster. He is in perfectly good health. He is taking a bit of a hiatus from the Saintsational forum for the time being.

very good to hear.
He is my favourite poster, apart from White Winmar (gregpackhamsheadband maybe?)

sainters85 wrote:

mbogo wrote:I was a little surprised Billings has kicked 21/34 this year. Even 50/50 ratio and we might be in these finals. Some serious work is needed here, as he is the most inaccurate AFL forward ..

all between the eyes apparently. He was a beautiful kick for goal in the juniors

*ears

Jacks Back wrote:Haven't heard from Jiggster this week in the threads I've been reading have we? I hope he's alright.

I checked his history in the search option-
16 Aug is the most recent post.
No date for "last visited".

Not like him to be absent for this long.
Hope he's ok...

Winmar7 wrote:does anyone know what happened? no details about how he died, which always makes me think suicide...

How disgraceful to make this comment. "Details?" Are you next of kin?
They don't need to disclose if they don't wish to do so.

I was told by some ITK that we had a certain big fish " Signed, sealed and delivered", back in April. Their source would be in a position to know exactly what was going on. Now we know you cannot sign until end of season, so such a statement is not actually true, but an in principal agree...

In what alternative universe can the Dockers beat the Injectors at Etihad?

Seriously...

Ellaandjohn wrote:Think the match committee know exactly what they are doing. When has a decision cost us a game this year?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I believe you're using sarcasm

Not at all. Dees still one game ahead plus 7%
We will rue that Power failure (!)
because that's the bloody season-killer for sure.

i have doubts on Lonie, but he's definitely worth perservering with. Age and proper training will give him a more solid build. Way too early to write him off. Bit flummoxed why White got dropped, and would have liked to see him play. But we have our most experienced team on the park for Nick's fift...

Not sure why Newnes used the word 'successful'
when some improvements were obvious, but also some glaring flaws as well.
Successful is the wrong word.

I am not sure of the time when our final team needs to be lodged but Essendon start at 13:10 and we at 15:20. If Fremantle does NOT beat Essendon we are just playing a practice match. We should know by half time if Fremantle is trying or tanking. If so then Rice and White play. Not tanking, just no...

would hate to lose either of these warriors But have to trust the club with getting a very valuable player/s Because we can't get something for nothing. Giving up picks are fine, but a club might want an established proven player, if only for depth in their own list. Webster under contract/ Will the...

Player ratings mean Jack all, they hate Roberton. He's ranked 15th out of general defenders this year, but he's actually top 5 ? They arent gospel but they mean something. Why do people get their knickers in a knot over player rankings? It is just one methodology. Who cares? Noone 'hates' Roberton....

Not saying that I am ITK - but I know from a fairly reliable source that someone who is discussed on this forum as an 'alternate' has been in deep discussions regarding a long term contract Would this explain why Mav has been getting a regular game? Mav is great at blocking. Does this to perfection...

Maybe the club's staff have hit the right formula with developing Dunstan. I hope they learn from this... and apply to other players I agree with Wellard I mean MickThomas Wellard and Mick Thomas??? :shock: Maybe only for a short time? One did step in, the other step out. But which is our Monday's ...