Why would we want Sloane, this year proved he can't handle a tag, waste of money, waste of a draft pick. :roll: :roll: Maybe we’ll settle for Swallow? He’d probably do better. Only you know why you referenced that spud in a discussion about "don't tag me" Sloane. Swallow's nickname is Spi...

Wayne42 wrote:Why would we want Sloane, this year proved he can't handle a tag, waste of money, waste of a draft pick.

Maybe we’ll settle for Swallow? He’d probably do better.

parkeysainter wrote:

Saintly66 wrote:

saynta wrote:Sloane is a certainty. Sammy said so.

If we get him we’ll want to win the flag with him by the time he’s 31-32.

Its a massive chance we will get him. I have heard this also.

Always thought maybe them getting Gibbs part of the reason could have been in case Sloane is gone at seasons end.

The banks and the justice system don’t explain their reasoning you seriously expect the St Kilda Football club to?

Interesting question. I don't watch any VFL so I am wondering how NOK compares with someone like Eli Templeton? I think Eli had a better year, but Nick has more upside. Yep agreed, won the calders best and fairest and was in the all Australian under 18s side the kid is definitely no slouch and just...

Big loss but he can be replaced. It was only a matter of time before he got poached for a CEO or AFL role such is his talent. Guess all those Saints fans that thought he was no good will be happy now. Hmph. I thought she was a guru and a master and dedicated to the saints cause? Surely he is irrepl...

Why doesn't the AFL set up a separate transgender league. In all seriousness - this is the only viable solution. If it were to be over turned and she plays against XX women the possibility of a law suit when she hurts another girl is what will be stopping the AFL sanctioning her playing - after all...

saynta wrote:Sloane is a certainty. Sammy said so.

If we get him we’ll want to win the flag with him by the time he’s 31-32.

I thought that the club had an "understanding" with Talia that they would pick him up as a DFA. Will that happen now that Austin has arrived as a tall backman??? i.e. does anybody know how committed we were with Talia? and is there a need to have both Talia and Austin on the list? (Maybe ...

He is a loss because of his IP, but the cemetery is full of indispensable people. All the best, Ameet. Thanks for your service. Everybody these days works under the ever-watchful eye of the KPI demon. Except Bains appears to be immune and exempt from KPI and is apparently above reproach. He has rea...

parkeysainter wrote:The club should start plotting a major Sloane deal. Start the ball rolling now. The guy has done his part for Adelaide and has been loyal. Time to come back to big Melbs.

We should go after Sloane, have a strong feeling we’ll really be into gaff to address outside run.

and Marshall should be promoted imo. . Why? 1/ He was still raw last year. There was a lot to like, but he still needs to improve. 2/ I believe that from 2018 on that clubs can freely play rookies in the firsts if they choose too. NOK to be elevated and pierce to the rookie list before Marshall is ...

Sh*t happens I guess
Wonder if the delistings have already been sorted? Who else would have the major say now?

Word is will either be delisted or upgraded to the senior list and a tall (probably Pierce) will be put on the rookie list. NOK position is now more favourable after the trade period that isn’t to say he won’t be gone.

Hey guys, was just wondering what people’s thoughts were on NOK if he will be delisted or put on for another year?
Think if given the opportunity he’d be great for us.

BJ was pushed out, well under offer made which they new he wouldn't take . No different to Dal , cant pick and choose favourites. Loyal add Breen to that list . Club would have folded if he and others didn't accept the 27.5c in the dollar back in the late 70's its a job now and like any job when a ...

I CANNOT FUXKING BELIEVE OUR KICKING FOR GOAL HAS NOT BEEN ADDRESSED BY GETTING IN A RAFT OF f****** PSYCHOLOGISTS AND GOAL KICKING COACHES AND GETTING INSIDE THESE PLAYERS HEADS. Why hasn't Gresham gone back to Sandringham to learn how to do the basics? It's called being a love child, pulls the ol...

Love Gresham, safe to say he needs to get this whole "need to hog the ball" out of his game had it since juniors. Pathetic.

Eff this campaigner Lonie off already, plays like he's a millionaire.

Ricey in that team or am I going blind? He injured his ankle in the VFL so will probably miss this week was the week before he got injured- did he do it again? as he played last week Looked to be playing sore last week. Just making sure no more damage. Yeah think people took it as him being disinte...

Ricey in that team or am I going blind?

Another debutant next week for sure.

Not sure what all of you think, but I've watched Bailey Rice's intensity and it is absolutely not up to AFL standard. He just doesn't chase hard at all. Thought he's looked pretty solid all day. Looked solid, watching him when the song was sung he looked like he couldn't care I reckon he was feelin...

IN: J. Webster, B. Longer, L. Dunstan, B. Acres, R. Marshall
OUT: S. Gilbert (hand), T. Hickey (omitted), D. McKenzie (omitted) B. Long (omitted), J. Battle (omitted)

Rice done for the day has his ankle strapped.