SaintPav wrote: ↑Wed 12 Apr 2023 5:42pm Who was the question hog?

Mitch Cleary

The_Dud wrote: ↑Sun 16 Oct 2022 4:06pm Does Ross even want to coach?

Has had plenty of opportunities which he seems to turn down pretty quick. I think maybe he just likes the attention.

Also, why would he leave his cushy media gigs for coaching and everything that comes with it?

I can think of 5 million reasons!

SaintPav wrote: ↑Sun 16 Oct 2022 11:15am Really need a third tall as well as a breakaway mid.

Hayes when he recovers from his ACL injury & Sharman give us a bit of depth in that department. And also Wood & Highmore.

I’m looking forward to Owens & Windhagers development. Both have a bit of toe & are a little different.

Many of the done deals are being held over until tomorrow afternoon/evening to create ‘drama’ for the end of the trade period. I suspect Higgins trade fits into this category.

johnearljames wrote: ↑Thu 29 Oct 2020 8:28pm 2021 starts tomorrow.

Welcome Crouchy.

Can go any forum.

Saynta is the forums Joe Biden. Absolute lemon of a bloke.

jaxons wrote: ↑Sat 12 Oct 2019 3:42pm Article was written by a Bulldogs supporter.
No chance he doesn't come to St.Kilda.

Do you see us getting all our trades completed Jaxons?

st.byron wrote: ↑Sat 12 Oct 2019 2:34pm Not so sure we want Gray AND Butler. One or the other it seems.

Gray has elected to re-sign with Port for one year. Butler will be a Saint for a late pick.

desertsaint, brilliant post.

I think they should definitely taken M King and B King but at #3 and #6 and still taken Rankine But they did not thankfully. Max will be a far better player than Lukocious... although we might have taken Rozee if Max was gone? If GC had taken the King boys at 2 & 3 I think we would’ve taken Luk...

GC should’ve taken Max & Ben at 2 & 3 especially losing May & Lynch in the same off season. Nah I would prefer my club to back themselves in and draft on talent - especially if there are better rated players at 2 and 3 (which was obviously the opinion of the Suns and many other draft an...

GC should’ve taken Max & Ben at 2 & 3 especially losing May & Lynch in the same off season. Nah I would prefer my club to back themselves in and draft on talent - especially if there are better rated players at 2 and 3 (which was obviously the opinion of the Suns and many other draft an...

jaxons wrote: ↑Fri 04 Oct 2019 10:25pm

Myron Gaines wrote: ↑Fri 04 Oct 2019 10:17pm My guess/hope: Ollie Wines.

Right club, different player.

Can I buy a vowel?

Through media reporting we know we have spoken to Paddy Ryder, Sam Gray & Dougal Howard. Is it one of those players or someone different?

My guess/hope: Ollie Wines.

I think they should definitely taken M King and B King but at #3 and #6 and still taken Rankine But they did not thankfully. Max will be a far better player than Lukocious... although we might have taken Rozee if Max was gone? If GC had taken the King boys at 2 & 3 I think we would’ve taken Luk...

GC should’ve taken Max & Ben at 2 & 3 especially losing May & Lynch in the same off season.

Trade Bruce...Is the club undertaking rebuild mk2?

What the club pitches to him & what actually occurs are two separate things. 1/ Wow. That would be the most likely way ever to completely stuff a club. Lie to all players deliberately before they even arrive. 2/ The strategy you are stating that the club has then is that they will figure things...

Would we trade Ben Long for him? We have a number of small forwards on the list & not many medium forwards. It’s worth considering.

Back to Ryder Someone tell me where he plays when Marshall spends 70% of the game in the ruck? Forward & if that doesn’t work then he plays for Sandy. What the club pitches to him & what actually occurs are two separate things. He needs to perform as a forward which you clearly believe he w...

It makes sense to announce the head coach next week when no footy is on. Equally it made sense this week however I imagine they were still going through the process. My guess is next Tuesday.

I’d do it. However the players won’t accept to rot on the Gold Coast. Only 1. players looking to "transition into retirement", on good coin, or 2. players who know they are not really up to AFL standard, want to play for Gold Coast Sadly this partly applies to St Kilda as well. Our player...

Do you think that’s what Ryder’s thinking. He wants to leave Port because he’s not #1 and they found out (as we will) two ruckmen do not work. Ryder is a useless forward The pitch would include both Marshall & Ryder in the 22. If that doesn’t work then Ryder plays at Sandy & is backup. Simp...

Anything that involves Rowan spending time out of the ruck is so stupid it’s hard to contemplate He’s about to win a b&f playing in that position I don’t believe getting Ryder would mean Marshall spends more time away from the ruck. This year Marshall was in the top 3-4 ruckman in the competiti...

Paddy Ryder will cost pick 60+ & a 2 x 400-500k contract. As a redundancy for Marshall & who can also play forward it’s a no brainer selection. I don’t get the fuss. I also imagine the club will be looking at a <21 year old developing ruckman.