Sorry - whilst I sat there trying to find 5 players and then post the votes, this thread was created , so I repost my votes here without comment.

5. Nasiah W-M
4. Steele
3. Wood
2. King
1. Stocker

Today is my birthday. All the Saints gave me was some junk time goals. So depressing. 5. Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera. Far from perfect , but our best ball user. At age 21, seems to be our most poised, mature player. 4. Jack Steele. Our best midfielder ( yes I know that equates to being the best ice hock...

If Heath, Crouch, Membrey, Clark and Hotton don’t get a gig next week then our selection team are a joke. Caminiti, Collard, Sharman, Ross and Windhager can go back and find some form. Based on the VFL stats today , those seem to be the 5 ins. I agree the outs, save for Windhager. There may be othe...

I did not see the game. Based purely on the stats, Max Heath is starting to impress , Clark and Membrey look due for a return to Seniors ( there seem to be multiple spots available) and Hotton is starting to find his feet . Crouch found a lot of it. Do you think we should take Max Heath to Perth nex...

If , on the AFL website, you go to the “Summary “ section, and hover over the goal we scored at 27.49 in 3rd, you will see that Hotton kicked it and has 5.0.

Bump - although judging from the scores and your comments, I don’t imagine there will be a rush for people to lodge votes.

I am overseas for work and have no access to the game, so I will leave it to others to populate this thread. I will back for the Dees game and will aim to start the voting thread for that game.

Go Saints !

Could be worse - he might have picked the Washington Generals.

So great to have Eric on board- definitely a hard-core Saint.

No worries, Fonzie !

It is possible that Amon got the 5 and 2, and RoMa the 4 and 3. I think however that your prognostication is more likely to be spot on.

5. Jack Steele. Kept lifting . Great desire. 4. Rowan Marshall . His opponent was excellent, but Rowan was even better, especially late. 3. Josh Battle. 2. Cal Wilkie. 1. Riley Bonner. Superb early. Less so later on, but I think only the four players above went past him. In good news for all Saints ...

Ahh, Pelchen & Watters Richo & Lethlean Lerhman & Higgins Bourke & Wills Andrews & Cwealth Games Downer & East Timor Siegfried & Roy Hayden Haitana & Fine Cotton Milli & Vanilli Yorkeys - I have to pick you up on this one. It was Hayden Haitana and Bold Personali...

Probably rest a Garcia or Hastie for Henry I’d like to see Shoenmakers for Bonner but not sure they’d do it If Dow performs he has to be considered…Steel needs help Be great to have some pressure for spots I’d have rested Marshall today …maybe next week? I suggest the following. 1. Henry to high ha...

Ross post-game said Liam Henry trained well today and will come straight in next week. There are a few candidates to make way for him.

Mattaes very disappointing. He is still a teenager for another 7.5 months ,and I think long term he will be very valuable , but right now he does not deserve a spot .

If his first name was Brian he might be the Messiah.. or perhaps a Beach Boy .

5. Jack Sinclair
4, Darcy Wilson
3. Marcus Windhager
2. Jack Hayes
1. Josh Battle.

Hill , Wood , Marshall, NWM also good.

Much better, Max - good contested mark .

The difference between Hayes and King - in attitude and endeavour and impact - is stark

Only 6 players selected for neither seniors nor Sandy - Butler , Higgins, Crouch, Van Es, Henry and Hotton. Cordy named as emergency for seniors but also listed as being rested and not named for Sandy so looks like he will be rested. All bar Hotton are on our published injury list . Not sure what th...

Not for me thanks- I will be away for work

Congratulations to Jack Hayes on fighting back from two years of injuries to earn senior selection. Not to put a dampener on it but he did play late last year against Brisbane at the Gabba. Sorry about that - I missed that game , visiting my daughter overseas. In any event, I am glad he has another...

Congratulations to Jack Hayes on fighting back from two years of injuries to earn senior selection.

Hastie did a few nice things, but was twice beaten one-on-one by Burgoyne. Worth a start next week for sure, but I am not totally enthused yet. Anyway, good luck to him.

5. Jack Sinclair. 3. Rowan Marshall. When he went down, the world was coming to an end, but he did a Gary Lazarus and fought on manfully all night. 2. Cal Wilkie . So reliable. 2. Darcy Wilson. Really looking the goods. 2. Marcus Windhager . Strong in and under. 1. Brad Hill. Superb early. Faded a b...

What's the point of all of this? We had a great ANZAC Day ceremony before the Pies vs the Bombers yesterday. ANZAC day is over. If AFL were played over Xmas-New Year, would Santa show up before the game on Boxing Day? Is that a rhetorical question, or do you genuinely want to be educated as to the ...