fingers wrote:

Saint_J wrote:hate to say it but think Shenton could also be out... looked abit out of his depth tonight. Ritcho had him forward as well?

Shenton just had his contract extended.

well there goes that one!

on TV was shown in full... credit to Sam even with his pants down didn't stop trying to win the ball!

pulls that crap a lot. also great to see ducker selwood try one on and get ignored by the ump.

hate to say it but think Shenton could also be out... looked abit out of his depth tonight. Ritcho had him forward as well?

Motlop was so damaging tonight... would love to have him at the Saints..

Funny thing Richo umpire call was right, Scott they got it wrong lol. sides of the fence.

time to stop the gilbo bashing guy was a monster tonight. all players make meals of it at times...

Toy Saint wrote:It was the ideal compeditor for Holmes, Blixarse is a clean steeplechaser, whereas Sandilands and Mumford and strong bodied monsters

we might get to see him with Nick Nat that will be a very strong test for him.

shenton lost some charm post haircut... looked abit out of depth tonight..

kosifantutti wrote:Holmes has a lot of upside but I don't think much came from his hit outs. I would have played Hickey all year.

think one or two lead to Minch goal

Agree with op. Motlop was probably bog but pulling out one decision after the game was typical bias crap from chamnel 7. There were loads of controversial decisions. Many against one. Picking out one after the game just made Ling a redheaded flog. Also annoyed me how Ling crapped on about Hugh Godd...

kosifantutti wrote:I don't recall the Motlop one but on 3AW it was all about the non 50 to Weller.

C7 scientists all about it games end.

Con Gorozidis wrote:Great problem to have. We hold all the aces here.
Looking fwd to apology from BigMart.

Hickey was massive tonight.

think they should also mention we missed out on a few in our 50 that would have iced the game as well. but no mention of them... just that one.

didn't win but for me great game 2nd to the bombers drubbing. (if only Jimmy got the sack after we smashed them)

according to the eggsperts the Motlop call some how cost them the game and the finals.

sour grapes.

Jason Blake got 2 Brownlow votes in his whole career. Maybe should have gotten rid of him in 1998 Err are you retarded? Noone wants to get rid of Gilbert. The question is is he good enough to play until he is 33? If hes not even in our top ten when he is 27/28 then unlikely he will make it to 33. d...

Sorry Billy, if anyone is trade bait you might be in-front atm. Holmes great first game... did alot better then i had expected. can only see upside! Hickey excellent game. still can't understand why he played so much in the VFL. Tap work by Holmes unreal. great to see so many to our advantage. will ...

YES!!!!!! very bloody important... kicked a real needed goal. good on ya Gilbo!

elizabethr wrote:Steven the turnover King

that holding the ball hurt but .... that's footy

what a exciting game... heart in the guts stuff.

Minch not in the middle that much disappointing. but the boys kept going while the cats threatened over and over to take it.

1000 times better then last week. Holmes very good first game considering.

The Fireman wrote:Longer is taking longer than I thought.

third year in the system for Longer, or 2nd?

S.A Saint wrote:What im miffed about is gilbert being in the centre bounce.. For heavens sake get him out of there and give minch/acres in there!!

this!

kalsaint wrote:Thoroughly disappointed and pissed off that the club can capitulate in this way. Effort can only go so far. Kicking must be addressed to provide hope that its all worth it.

yep i've got that robbed feeling as well. half time was thinking we were home.

Holding the ball and high tackle rules have been applied really inconsistently in the second half. Saunders got swung 360 over the line and pinged, the north bloke did the same thing for a throw in. Roberton gets headlocked for no free where Boomer and Higgins got frees for ducking. Not much of an ...

Holding the ball and high tackle rules have been applied really inconsistently in the second half. Saunders got swung 360 over the line and pinged, the north bloke did the same thing for a throw in. Roberton gets headlocked for no free where Boomer and Higgins got frees for ducking. Not much of an ...