We need at least 2 first rounders to play with, if we want to get Hill & King. We've got one, how do we get the other? Gold Coast will want our 5 and something else for King. Fair enough too. Freo will want a first rounder for Hill. Here's a possibility, Pick 5 for Hill, just get it done. Bruce,...

Nick_BlueNRG wrote: ↑Sat 31 Aug 2019 10:54am Carlisle, Geary and pick 5 for Ben King.

First question - Would you be happy with this trade?
Second question - Would Gold Coast accept this?

Discuss.

Would you have us bend ourselves over?

From St Kilda along the bayside to Frankston, that's our home. I would also suggest its more heavily populated than all of Tasmania. We shouldn't even hypothetically think of such nonsense, leave that to the Gold Coast or North. But when you say that about the Tasmanian population are you counting ...

From St Kilda along the bayside to Frankston, that's our home. I would also suggest its more heavily populated than all of Tasmania. We shouldn't even hypothetically think of such nonsense, leave that to the Gold Coast or North. I agree there is a long history in the Bay. I think it would be hard t...

From St Kilda along the bayside to Frankston, that's our home. I would also suggest its more heavily populated than all of Tasmania.

We shouldn't even hypothetically think of such nonsense, leave that to the Gold Coast or North.

Carlton have delisted Lobbe. Would he do as a back up at Sandy? Certainly cheaper than Ryder.

A protruding disk putting pressure on a nerve renders you a cripple - and in agony unable to move The initial response is physio (where they can not get anywhere near where the problem is initially because of pain) and if that is not successful surgery, which is complicated with risk Surgery is the...

I’d prefer he has a crack all the time Effort is a non negotiable, can’t pick and choose... that’s a sign of character He’s the sort of player that’d let you down in a big game due to his attitude being less than average I was disgusted by his last game Granted his last game was poor, he had a few ...

This means we're gong to trade Bruce.

It appears that Ratten, Harvey & Longmuir (perhaps B Scott) are the only candidates.

No sign of Lyon or anyone else, unless its been kept quiet.

He's worth a look, although I'd prefer Hill.

Lets get St.Kilda people with passion for our club running the club. Not Zig and Zag who are their for their own self centred egos and slowly destroying the club. Do we want Paddy Ryder i say NO past his best and will certainly not have his heart in it i think. Offering big money for a player who m...

Its about money, Carlisle is well paid and the Club want room for Hill and whomever else. So the Club has opened up the option of trading Carlisle or extending him on reduced money. Given his age and possible injury, I reckon we'll extend him with a pay cut, as I don't think another Club will take h...

B.M wrote: ↑Mon 26 Aug 2019 8:26pm Good ball users?

He marks uncontested in the d50

Turns sideways and kicks 20m toward the boundary... and he f***ed that twice kicking off one step, because he’s lazy.

Probably bored, sort of player that shines in the big ones. Lazy or a tad over confident?

Ducks and drakes I think. Carlisle obviously wants to extend and the Club wants to leverage.

Like we have an abundance of quality key defenders. We'll keep him and do a deal. Forget his games this year, although he probably won us a few. He's a calm, cool and collected gun.

They just need to bite the bullet and relocate them to Tasmania and while they're at it, relocate GWS permanently to Canberra. They don't need more draft picks, they still have trouble keeping any good players! No one cares about AFL (or indeed sport in general) on the Gold Coast. I cannot believe ...

Richmond look the team to beat.

They just need to bite the bullet and relocate them to Tasmania and while they're at it, relocate GWS permanently to Canberra. They don't need more draft picks, they still have trouble keeping any good players! No one cares about AFL (or indeed sport in general) on the Gold Coast. I cannot believe t...

Although, overall I'm a fan of GT, it started with his ridiculous player contracts. Leaving us no flexibility in List Management for perhaps Lyon's entire tenure. A rebuild was then delayed and it had to be, because we were in Premiership contention. Then the main cause, the election of the incompet...

Lonie! Should be one of the first half dozen picked every week. A couple of ordinary games and people want him out!

Newnes, I agree on, but we're going to have to sacrifice a bit more. Ross and/or Acres will have currency.

Carlisle's strength is that he's cool in the contest, unfussed, relaxed and confident. That means he's good under pressure and creative. The downside is, when he loses a little focus, you get what you got yesterday. He's elite, glorious hands and elite by foot. He's at his best across half back, int...

Yesterday’s game was utterly irrelevant. Players had already checked out for the season.

Given where we came from and the fact that we didn’t play great footy, 6.

Riewoldt suggesting that it is "slim" chance for him coming to the saints next year on AFL 360. Riewoldt wasn't exactly bullish on Ratten's chances On The Couch last night. Sorted smirked in an "I know something...." manner. Not that I'm sure of that, but he did smirk. Tony74 ar...

IN ROSS WE TRUST Get it done! Surely you jest No, he's the best available by a country mile, Freo are nuts! No thanks. He is a prick, tosser and a loser. Walked out on the club before after leaving us srtipped bare. Walked out after been treated appallingly. Anyone with any self respect would have ...