I like Membrey don't get me wrong, but his form has been ordinary for weeks now and should have been subbed off not Hayes. What would have happened if Marshall went down, I dont understand there logic! Hayes has good forward craft as well. Also one more point, when Marshall grabs the ball from the R...

Do you think they are up to it? If so happy to discuss..

It was a good win mate not being negative, but it was Nth Melbourne remember....
With Dow, Henry & Clarke to come back in, it will sort itself out!

In my opinion aren't up to it and are butchers by foot. Byrnes came on the field at the 10-minute mark of the third quarter and by halfway through the last looked spent.... He is poor by foot and shouldn't be the kicker inside 50 to our forwards... Bonner tries to take on too much by foot and is emb...

Darcy is going great and still has plenty of up side ahead of him! Knowing his Dad Mick I reckon when Darcy got cleaned up by Wardlaw he would have been yelling at the TV get up Boy, give them nothing.... Hard man Darcy's Dad...

Only Knock on him Mate is he is very outside... I have seen him play all through his JNR's from u12's to u18's, but has always had the class to read the game and run hard to the right places..As my Son keeps reminding me the AFL has changed and not everyone is required to run inside and get there ow...

Absolutely stoked! The gold with Darcy apart from his athletic ability is that he has been driven from an early age. I remember numerous times being at my house and choosing to drink water rather than softdrink or eating fruit instead of chips and lollies... And that was at a young age aswell.. Unde...

Won Murray Bushrangers B/F this year aswell...

Yeah agreed Saint Lee. I was having a beer with his Dad a month ago and he stated that Adelaide are pretty keen on him.Adelaide have been keeping tabs on him the last couple of years, 2 years ago the crows couldnt believe his time/ trial runs he was doing as a 16 yr old . He comes from a great sport...

Alway destined to play Afl , very dedicated kid that has excelled in any sport he chooses. Darcy lives down the road from me in the same street and hung around my young bloke playing cricket , footy and B Ball. Was up until last year in the Vic U/18's cricket program selected as a promising fast bow...

Am I the only one that is worried about Ben Paton? I find his decision making poor, and he often turns the footy over by foot and nearly always hanpasses the ball to either some player standing flat footed and not expecting the ball.
He never looks clean with the footy.

Yeah Agreed.. I think Jones, Billings wont get back in. They will need a good spell at Sandy and need to bang the door down to have any chance.

Goddard considers himself a Bombers person, he has stated this publicly on numerous occassions when asked! Don't want him back now , he can piss off as far as I am concerned..

Like everyone on here I was glued to trade radio and was listening for some news if any about potential trades or trading of picks to get higher up in the draft order, but unfortunately nothing was reported. I believe Gallagher and the club fell asleep at the wheel here, all I heard our list boss ta...

I think we need him more then he needs us! I'm sure a lot of the older players that still have a great relationship with him have heavily endorsed him, if not pleaded with the club to get him back as senior coach. If appointed by the club I'm sure some players wont like his approach as Riewoldt has ...

Has to be Lyon.

I for one was Filthy when Ross left us and wished him nothing but failure at Freo, but as good coaches do they succeed where ever they go. It didnt take him long at Freo to turn them into a top four contender and even playing off in a GF. As I am a bit older and wiser now I do understand that there ...

I found it strange that Brad Scott when asked by the media what game plan and style of football do you hope to play ,his response was I quote " I have to get to know the the players strenghts and weakness's first " . Wouldn't you think this guy would have given a better response then that ...

Who cares about Nth Melbourne mate............................ He is a relatively knew coach chook????? At least Nth realised their issues with their defence and went and got Tudor to assist with that issue................ Has he departed Nth yet??????? Also apart from finals footy,which we all know...

Who cares about Nth Melbourne mate............................ He is a relatively knew coach chook????? At least Nth realised their issues with their defence and went and got Tudor to assist with that issue................ Has he departed Nth yet??????? Also apart from finals footy,which we all know...

Hey Chook,
Ross Lyons' game plan has not evolved since 2005.................................
He departs assistants to deflect blame from his outdated coaching techniques.
No plan B mate,you must score goals to win finals mate????????
You can't defend all day chook.....................

So the point is chook , he will always deflect the blame for losing......... It is pretty obvious chook numerous assistants under Ross offer suggestions to improve game- plan, but why hasn't Ross altered his coaching ideals since 2005???? The simplistic answer is "He can't....it is that simple ...

Ross is always turning over his assistants,but more noticeable is when his team loses finals.
His assistants always seem to be the fall guys with Ross.......but as they say the buck stops with the coach doesn't it?????????

Geez people are harsh on Longer!!!!!!!!!!!!! The kid is 22 and rucked all day like Goldstein does for the kangaroos and dominated,clear tapouts to midfielders and second efforts in clearences were inspiring ??? Billy is the future and only going to get better. It doesn't matter who he rucked against...

Agreed.....Soft as butter and we can't even rotate him through the midfield.
Most small forwards must be able to go in the midfield at some stage.
Can't even call him a 1 trick pony,because he doesn't posess a trick????