B.M wrote: ↑Sat 08 Jul 2023 11:36pm What’s the right price?

And wtf rucks if we trade Marshall?

What about for Grundy and Petracca/Oliver?
Ok that’s a bit fanciful, let’s say a top midfielder and a reasonable tap ruckman?
?

Scollop wrote: ↑Sat 08 Jul 2023 11:47pm Crouch was good too

He was fine.
Just not sure he cops thaw amount of vitriol directed at the other three.

I thought Byrnes was good, tried to take the game on Billings great apart from missing that open goal, nice little tap to Gresham in first quarter won’t appear in the stats. Gresham could take some lessons in unselfishness! Howard more good than bad, he just shouldn’t stop and think just do the Seb ...

Good to see Steele more involved.

Hill is a good example of an outside player with courage. It's been so long since I've seen Billings play, that I can't recall if he has it. You sir are a comedian! If I had to name 100 outside AFL players with courage not sure I'd find a spot for Hill, his sense of self preservation reigns supreme...

Tongue better than Root?

Can anybody tell me who their half back who will mop up 40 times is?
Not sure it’s happened enough times for our coaches to have formulated a plan to combat it.

Nothing to be nervous about.
Season over after Hawks game, time for exploration now.

What are all our genius coaches doing about it?
Surely the players don’t just go it and land it on Zking’s head contrary to instructions??

tony74 wrote: ↑Sun 25 Jun 2023 5:16pm We did lose a very popular fitness coach

Lyon known for high turnover of assistant coaches.

Otiman wrote: ↑Thu 22 Jun 2023 3:13pm Don't care unless it affects us.

Didn't give a rats about JDG's shenanigans either until he was linked to us with a trade.

That said, if Oliver wants to come to us, I think i'd ignore just about any rumour.

Leave Melbourne to go to Saints?

Oh well, I suppose Charles left Diana for Camilla!!

Wouldn’t rush out to buy a house from him! Softened the sarcasm slightly but the 2009-2011 levels of bulls*** still prevail. A year of exploration but we will continue to select Steele and Wood clearly injury limited! He thinks he’s the smartest bloke in the room and interesting as well! It's now w...

Wouldn’t rush out to buy a house from him!
Softened the sarcasm slightly but the 2009-2011 levels of bulls*** still prevail.

A year of exploration but we will continue to select Steele and Wood clearly injury limited!
He thinks he’s the smartest bloke in the room and interesting as well!

:? Billings is 27, is pigeon holed as a player we have plenty of others playing. Injuries are less of a worry than form/ability and position. Needs to reinvent himself as a midfielder or be traded/delisted. Minimal trade value - 3rd or 4th rounder. McKenzie is 26 and off some good form. I'm not sure...

Midfielder or not he was a grand final specialist.
If a couple of his teammates had his heart we would have 3 flags and a statue of Goddard at Linton st.

Hannebery, Hill recruitment debacles going to haunt us for a decade or more.
Leadership vacuum caused by going for the mercensries instead of taking our medicine going right down and hitting the draft.
He who won’t be dropped provided great leadership and example, NOT!

SydneySainter wrote: ↑Sat 17 Jun 2023 11:35pm I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, St Kilda are just a sh**ty football club.

Bit harsh there mate!
Disappointing or heartbreaking instead of shi,,y and I will agree with you.

Waltzing St Kilda wrote: ↑Sat 17 Jun 2023 11:29pm Hiill getting votes? Gee whiz, that's generous.

People giving him votes for his Seb-like precision kicking into forward line.
We’ll blame the conditions i suppose

Atrocious in the box tonight Failed to Adjust style of play to conditions - allowing them to have a spare in the second quarter and half - not getting Sincs around the footy (it wasn’t a rebounding game! Players adjusted by halfway through the third - too late Lol Here we go Coaches don’t matter …b...

Need to hit the weights room in off season, too often outmuscled in one on ones. Too many headless chooks kicking forward, Ross and Hill the worst but lots of others not far behind. If that’s all Steele can do in his current condition he needs rest. Windhager and Phillipou the bright spots on a dirt...

They are starting to remind me of Saints 2002-2003

Fantastic group of young players assembled in a couple of years without having to completely bottom out!
Was Windhager any good last night?
He had middling type stats but they don’t always tell us the full story.

Was Caminiti poor last night?
I didn’t see the game just kept checking scores on my phone.

Didn’t see the game but absolutely love what Owens brings.

He,s a cross between Barry Lawrence and (pre injury) kozi!
The fact that he’s so versatile is the biggest plus.
Not sure about his leadership aspirations but potential captain say 2025?

Otiman wrote: ↑Sat 03 Jun 2023 7:38pm Butters
Bont
Greene

Who do you drop from current best 22 to fit them in?