Membrey wasn't available against Sicily and last week was his first week back I'd be inclined to play Tim on Tom Having said that, maybe Coops can surprise me and maybe he's ready to take another scalp I am not sure that Membrey has played as a defensive forward? Plus Stewart is 2 cm taller than Me...

Sharman is the obvious tall out. So Sharman went how against Sicily? So Sharman went how against Vlastuin? Just as well Geelong do not have Tom Stewart playing.... Sicily had really good numbers and was the 3rd highest ranked player for the Hawks. Sicily was reduced largely to getting cheap out the...

Sharman is the obvious tall out. So Sharman went how against Sicily? So Sharman went how against Vlastuin? Just as well Geelong do not have Tom Stewart playing.... Sicily had really good numbers and was the 3rd highest ranked player for the Hawks. Sherman had an average game against the Tiges and w...

Vortex wrote: ↑Tue 15 Aug 2023 8:04pm

Sharman is the obvious tall out.

So Sharman went how against Sicily?

So Sharman went how against Vlastuin?


Just as well Geelong do not have Tom Stewart playing....

Do you need a good leader/coach - yes But does a good leader/coach guarantee success - no And has anyone ever said a good coach alone would guarantee success? = no Successful teams do most things right. Coaching is just one of multiple factors that need to be gotten right. But without a good coach ...

I think while our injuries have provided opportunity to get games into the kids, that RTB has actually erred on putting even more games into them than injuries alone required. This will help us going forward. Caminiti for example now knows that he neds to build his body up if he wants to play key fo...

Vortex Is hilarious...could be a stand up comedian at the saints disco back in the day ..too smart for his own good ..but he did cream his pants with that Cooper goal . it was a good goal, I love goals, my a favorite part of the game, but why did he get subbed out, I apologise in advance if I have ...

Devilhead wrote: ↑Sun 06 Aug 2023 3:34pm you need a watchafl.com.au account or Kayo thru VPN as mentioned before

Yes, to watch live.

Or on delay afl.com.au is free.

B.M wrote: ↑Wed 09 Aug 2023 4:47pm
They will want our first rounder!

No.. They want points plain and simple. They have 3 Academy players.

If you look at the list changes for this season we went for more youth. Ignoring everything else you would expect to slip. But to be better for it in a season or three. IN Anthony Caminiti (pre-season supplemental selection period), Zaine Cordy (free agent, Western Bulldogs), Olli Hotton (No.35 draf...

If you think Ross is happy with that performance you don’t know him. He doesn’t rave and rant but he’s not cuddly. He is honest and to the point. He takes no prisoners and knows what he wants. And if you don’t deliver you know. Trust me RTB needs to back it up with action during this trade period. ...

Duplicate post removed by sRr

If you think Ross is happy with that performance you don’t know him. He doesn’t rave and rant but he’s not cuddly. He is honest and to the point. He takes no prisoners and knows what he wants. And if you don’t deliver you know. Trust me RTB needs to back it up with action during this trade period. ...

If you have Kayo already, you can use a VPN but I found this very hit and miss. I think it now detects the VPN, and will not play till it is turned off, and then the geo locator blocks. I my recent trip though USA/Canada I watched my daughter's Foxtel account through a VPN and it work every time. H...

Interesting that he is selected in the side this week against Carlton with all the following medium to tall forwards (who have played that position this year) available- Caminiti, Phillipou, Cordy, Owens,( all selected) and arguably King, Membrey, Holmes( returning from injury) Holmes??? Is that yo...

I don't see a mass exodus coming. It really depends on whether the club is successful in trading in players and in gaining any free agents. If the club is active in that which is wat Stavro on Bigfooty is suggesting the club is trying to do, and probably where the "hearing" in the OP came...

Saint2 wrote: ↑Thu 03 Aug 2023 5:16pm Jones out, but looking at the game last week if we picked on form, then Webster's position would be a bit dodgy- for an experienced defender, he lost his opponent too much in the traffic.

Webster had a shocker last game. But has had a good season.

You do not drop players for one bad game.

Trev from the Bush wrote: ↑Wed 02 Aug 2023 7:34pm We are the Rodney Dangerfield of the AFL. No respect.

I am more hoping that we are the Steven Bradbury of the AFL...

Just depends which team turns up Both us and the opposition. If you look at Geelong they have been just as variable as we have been. Also the Tigers, and Blues. Lions as well, but not as much. Plus they are much better at the GABBA. Cats are definitely beatable if we play smart and fast football fo...

B.M wrote: ↑Tue 01 Aug 2023 8:32pm Caminiti is Key Position size

Sharman is not

Therefore they are different

Agree. Sharman is more your "third tall " type. He could well be our replacement for Membrey.

Otiman wrote: ↑Mon 31 Jul 2023 10:08pm
I just don't think he's the messiah.

Did anyone suggest he was this season?


He has only played 26 games.

He has shown enough of late to indicate that he should be retained for next season.

nobhead wrote: ↑Mon 31 Jul 2023 7:50pm Caminiti susp
Jones inj
Sharman inj

I have seen the first two confirmed today. Have not seen the third confirmed today. If a hamstring normally the scans would have been done and reported by now.

Anyone seen any reports?

3rd lowest stats and managed only 1 tackle and dropped a few sitters against the 3rd from the bottom. Ok, so Sharman and Bruest both only had 8 disposals. Both had ! tackle. 5 marks to Sharman, 6 to Bruest. Clearly both must have been crap with no influence on the game. I didn't watch Bruest that c...

Oh and some dude named Sicily had 22 intercept possessions and won the game for the Hawks last time. Sicily only had 8 this time. Now why was that? Who was his opponent this time?

Vortex wrote: ↑Mon 31 Jul 2023 6:40pm 3rd lowest stats and managed only 1 tackle and dropped a few sitters against the 3rd from the bottom.

Ok, so Sharman and Bruest both only had 8 disposals. Both had ! tackle. 5 marks to Sharman, 6 to Bruest.

Clearly both must have been crap with no influence on the game.