he's 195 and 98 kg fast and also a tad scary - we got destroyed by the tall forwards this year - how many bags of 5 against us ?? dawson had about 8 disposals and was seen as almost best on ground last week - all Walsh needs to do stay tight on a man , be menacing and make spoils - the odd kick mark...

Tommy Walsh has not exactly kicked goals in terms of game time this year at the swans - and we need a brute down back - can we get him back and let him play the hardened bigman in the back with big fisted spoils?? - seems he hasn't been given a chance to play a role but his been 'learning the craft'...

We need a ruck and backman brute - cloke might not get a game in our forward line

Zac Clarke for sure - not sure he's available but way ahead of minson - who i also think can play -But Clarke is only 22 is 202cm an athlete and from oakleigh chargers - bring him home !!

good bye games for sure - no reason to play the blake and Kos otherwise

IN: Newnes, Dunell, Milera, Markworth, Siposs, Ross OUT: Dempster (rest), Ray (rest), Milne (rest), Kosi (omit), Wilkes (omit), Hayes (rest) Agree with something like that also put NR on long term injury and bring in Archer as well Unless we have a cunning plan and play kosi - team instruction bein...

If he doesn't play this week - he may be in trouble - I think he will play this week - for the Saints before you ask

I haven't given up on him -( I've posted before with the same argument) he's still 20 and for a big guy thats young - needs to grow into his frame - the couple of times I've seen him - he has agility and hand skills - would like to see him loose a couple of kg and get some extra run and movement He'...

While we are talking about "what I said elsewhere" the club needs to come out and say Kosi has been playing under duress of injury and that he is not going play again this year - and then let him retire gracefully - good guy etc etc just needs to give it away

The best thing the club can do is announce a major injury to Kosi - let him step out with dignity "has been playing under duress since......" then he retires or if anyone at gws or somewhere would give us their last pick in the rookie draft or a years supply of linament oil for our first 1...

He is a great find

whoever taught him to kick needs to come down and teach the rest of them

@#$^&*()_++_)(*&^%$#$%^&*()_)(*^$#@#$%^&*()_+_)*&^$#@!

Have lost so many games these last few years due to foot skills - or lack of

YES benn saying it for years - we also need someone with some presence on the field( apart from Lenny) but someone a bit more menacing - have had it since Hamil - need to recruit a Leigh Brown type

Milne has been good this ye- can lace em with pride one more season

Tonight's performance is the straw that broke the camels back for me .... We can't win important games with Kosi in the team- he brings nothing - the only time he touched the ball he was free, had the sit over Bartel who was wrestling in goal square with another saint forward ( can't say who ? ) dro...

Not a fan - hope to be in the future

Well guys - not sure where this thread has gone - 14 pages and - no offense - can't be bothered reading them all - not sure how Milne/Obrien morphed into Milane - BUT my problem with this whole thing - and forgive me if this has been mentioned elsewhere - I would like to see the umpire put under inv...

On the reply it was 25 to 14 BEFORE the obrien free - so thats 26 to 14 - 9 to 2 in the last qtr - we were playing the ball and getting there first a good deal of the time in the last so no call for such discrepancy - Pies had 2 frees to make a goal in the first 1 minute of the last term - umpiring ...

On the reply it was 25 to 14 BEFORE the obrien free - so thats 26 to 14 - 9 to 2 in the last qtr - we were playing the ball and getting there first a good deal of the time in the last so no call for such discrepancy - Pies had 2 frees to make a goal in the first 1 minute of the last term - umpiring ...

Kosi - should be moved on I think - in his defence there were 2 or 3 scraggs on him which were atomatic frees at the other end - could have had 4 goals - my main problem with him is what happens for the rest of the game when he is not having his 2- 4 shots on goal - his opponent runs rampant at grou...

Siposs??

He has just improved 3 weeks overnight - he will probably play a match on Thursday

I'd have a look at.... Tom Campbell - Williamstown 201cm 101kg 20 years old Disposals: 11.4 (avg) Efficiency: 63.4% (avg) Hitouts: 32.3 (avg) Named in the best (top 6) 85.7% of the time this year then... Nicholas Meese - Northern Blues. 197cm 105kg 25 in 2013 Disposals: 13.1 Efficiency: 61% Hitouts...

listening on the radio - whats with milera - has had the ball taken off him 3 times in 5 mins???

I am ever the optimist with regard to Saints - pre season i saw them as being better then last year na d was happy to see Lyon go....why? Last year some top flighters had shocking years - Roo, Gilbert, we had injuries - lenny, Gwilt our mid tiers had room for improvement - Jack, armo and some of our...