Inexcusable from McCartin, honestly don't know what to go with him, he is becoming a liability nearly cost us the Newnes goal earlier. If we send him back to the vfl the pressure will continue to build on him but he just isn't afl quality and so far off a number 1 pick it isn't funny

Just a question, is it free entry for people with an AFL membership? Been a while since ive been to a game and thinking of heading down

Midfield class was the difference today, Selwood and co killed us in the second half. Gresham struggled today but such a disappointing game from Billings after last week, can't remember how many times he turned it over. Looking for a big response from him next week

Is there anyone more boring or monotone to listen to than Jimmy Bartel. Seriously what the hell is he doing out there? Basically interviewing his mates after every quarter, if that bloke can get a gig on tv anyone can

MC Gusto wrote:Billings can build from here

Agreed, seems to be a real confidence player. Just needs to add some polish and he will be ok

mullet wrote:this game is copping it on social media. TRASH they are calling it

Who cares, a win is a win. Collingwood are a pretty ordinary team

This goal kicking will cost us games, if it doesn't cost us today it will in the future. Honestly it's just not good enough

Keeping the filth in this with some horrible goal kicking

Nothing more certain than Dunstan missing a set shot from directly in front, would have to be one of the worst set shot kicks for goal in the league

They've only showed that ruck contest free kick half a dozen times already

Gresham is just so smooth, making the other mids look very sloppy

Few points from the first half - Defence has been excellent, Geary and Roberton have been huge whilst Carlisle is getting better every week - Goal kicking awful again, guys like Lonie shouldn't be in the team if they can't nail it from 25m straight in front - Billings low on confidence, getting more...

no chance of being delisted, hes 20 and consistently in the best in the VFL. Think about how long it took Ross to get a senior spot. Eli will be given at least another 2 years and I think will be a good 10 year player for us

Experts and punters were fooled by their winning streak early on this year. It is obvious Bolton looks to be a fantastic coach and real motivator, he is exactly what that club needed after the selfish disasterous tenure by Malthouse. However looking purely at the list, they have a few decent older p...

St Chris wrote:5. Newnes
4. Gresham
3. Membrey
2. Ross
1. Acres

+ 1

I like his pressure acts and speed. Not to fussed with how much of the ball he is getting I like him in the team

Carlton are just VFL standard today, if we are any good at all we need to win this by 100+ points. Haven't smashed a team at all this year

Easy to kick straight when the game is gone.. not good enough saints

The_Dud wrote:Have we kicked a goal tonight from further than 15m out??

nope so much so that Membrey happy to pass the responsibility when kicking from 45.

Surely Bruce needs a spell has been unlucky tonight but really had a poor year. Needs to find some form in the magoos

When Drew Petrie starts playing well you know we are in trouble.. this is getting hard to watch. Fancy boomer standing next to someone kicking from 5 meters for goal to get a cheapy.. typical of the blokes career

2 of our 4 goals have come from inside the goal square

In the biggest game of the season and probably for the past 5 years for the club the players just didn't stand up under pressure. Absolutely choked in front of goal and don't deserve to be talked about in finals calculations after this. Too many times this year in big games we have gone missing... a...

You are f*cking kidding me, this goal kicking is not even VFL level

FFS even the worst player in history to play 300 games is kicking goals against us