Billings before Bontempelli and MaCartin before Petracca fade into insignificance compared with Tambling before Franklin.

Wayne42 wrote: ↑Wed 08 Sep 2021 7:46pm How many flags do they use to signal a 0.7 goal.

1.4

Excuse me if im wrong, but what does going to Geelong have to do with his mental health? Im asking this question genuinely. Does he have access to some kind of support or treatment in Geelong that he wouldnt get an hour away in St Kilda? Because if you are suggesting that playing for a winning foot...

Excuse me if im wrong, but what does going to Geelong have to do with his mental health? Im asking this question genuinely. Does he have access to some kind of support or treatment in Geelong that he wouldnt get an hour away in St Kilda? Because if you are suggesting that playing for a winning foot...

I was just reading the thread on Jack Steven's trade to Geelong and am absolutely disgusted at some of the comments you all have made in relation to Jack's worth to the club. Nobody appears to have grasped the real issue here which is Jack's mental health. I'd give him to Geelong for nothing if it w...

Peter Bell was a flog when he was playing and obviously remains one still. Worse than Adrian Dodoro when it comes to trade negotiations. Tell him he's dreaming!!

Can you believe it? The Dockers are demanding two first round picks for B. Hill. So this year's pick 6 and next year's future first rounder. No team in the AFL, let alone the Saints are going to agree to that. It is way, way over what he is worth and Fremantle knows it. Apparently the conversation ...

Maybe we could get him yet preserve our first pick.

Steven to Geelong
Kelly to Freo
Hill to St Kilda

Win, win, win.

You only need to look at his bio (albeit brief) and you wouldn't be asking this question... "Marsh threw himself into draft contention after a great AFL Under-18 Championships with Western Australia. His performance against the Northern Territory, where he gathered 22 possessions and kicked fou...

Dan Hannebery's recruitment was a masterstroke... we have lost only 2 games since recruiting him... just sayin'

perhaps Paddy wouldn't have suffered all these concussions if the players up the field were able to deliver the ball into the forward line in a way that he wouldn't have to crash packs... just sayin'

For f**** sake you guys... take off your blinkers and consider the big picture. We have delisted 10 players and traded in 2, so we have to draft in 8. Before the pick swap we had picks 4, 28 67 and 79 meaning we would be required to draft in 4 players in the 90's or higher. Now with 4, 36, 46, 67 an...

The AFL website is reporting that Ben Long is attracting interest from both Melbourne and Essendon during this weeks trade discussions. Long is rated elite for kicking efficiency and one percenters and is the type of player we can ill afford to lose. I hope the powers at Linton Street rate him as hi...

There's talk around that GCS will take both Kings with selections 2 & 3. If Walsh is taken no 1 that leaves Lukosius at 4. Much better outcome don't you think?

In his career Shiel has kicked 61.73

Just what we need... another inacurate kick for goal!!

Another possible scenario is that Dunstan could be traded to Adelaide... they have an excess of outside mids and need inside grunt, and Luke is a SA boy. Perhaps a trade for Seedsman who is yet to re-sign with crows?

Bump

Bump

Why are we unable to do anything to correct this.

Because the coach is a dud!

Our coaching staff, our team, our disposal, our game plan (i could go on) are all RUBBISH.

I do feel sorry for Nick Coffield though... Looks like a player of the future - pity he's playing in a shite team.

Richardson certainly should be dropped.

Greg T wrote:The playing stock is simply not up to it

Individually the players are as good as on any other list. Collectively they dont gel as a team.

Coaching is what's not up to it!

shrodes wrote:We lost by 50 odd points and butchered the footy, the umpiring had nothing to do with it.

+1

Three weeks ago I posted here that St Kilda should sack Alan Richardson. Many of you disagreed, some even became abusive at my suggestion. So how many of you still think he's the right man for the job after today's pissweak effort? I stand by my earlier post.... SACK THE COACH!!!!

I'm fed up with hearing every year that "we'll be better this season" and then really failing to make an impact. Howl me down if you want to but the inconsistency and lack of pressure we have seen in the practice games is the result of one thing... poor coaching. Our list is every bit as g...