saynta wrote: ↑Wed 26 Oct 2022 2:08pm

B.M wrote: ↑Wed 26 Oct 2022 2:05pm I would take Zac Dawson over Dougal Howard anyday

Zac for a key defender, actually played within a bulls roar of his opponent

Old Dougal ‘zone off’ Howard is in for a rude awakening

You are on your own there mate.

No he is not.

I think there is two reasons as to why Lenny came back.

One - He hates seeing his old club as a nobody and wants to help us move out of that.
Two - Money... its a nicely paid job doing something he loves for a team loves.

Neither of them rely on who is the coach.

Adam Simpson will be happy

Sainternist wrote: ↑Tue 25 Oct 2022 3:10pm Who will be the new Z. Dawson?

Z. Cordy?

The real question is …. Who will be the Troy Schwarze of this lot?

I think Ross will will love D-Mac.
A player who gives 100%, 100% of the time.
I also think D-Mac will flourish under Ross too

Email I just received..... I hope you are well. I am pleased to be providing you with an exciting update. On behalf of the Board, I would like to announce that Ross Lyon has been appointed as the Senior Coach of our men’s AFL program. With more than 35 years’ experience in the AFL as a player, coach...

For the love of god can we please hurry up and name Lyon coach? Although, I’m not a huge fan of him coming back, it’s obviously a done deal. Just announce it so everyone can move on. I want an early announcement, a proactive draft period and then I don’t want to hear about our club until early next ...

Surely Sinclair can squeeze onto this list somewhere?

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 18 Oct 2022 12:00pm They should talk to Ferrari about plan B. They also have plan C and D

Still never makes a difference

YEP!! Lets get the coach that was SOUNDLY OUTCOACHED in THREE Grand finals (four if you count the draw) This bloke took a squad that included: Ball, Goddard, Hayes, Dal Santo, Montagna, Riewoldt, Kositzche, Milne, Gardner to the "big dance" to be beaten! Same story with Freo! Sandilands, ...

I love the AFLW.
Yes the Saints have a long way to go.
I'm all for a pride round and inclusiveness.
However, I thought the Jumper sucked. There were a lot of awesome Jumpers this weekend but I really disliked ours.
Hopefully they can improve on their skills and the Jumper in the future.

It’s a no for me.

I went back to the ex once and whilst it was a good night, it caused more pain and troubles in the long run.

Tempting ..

I’m not someone who has ever said “I’m not renewing my memberhip if….”
However!
I will 100% not renew my membership if I see James Hird announced as coach.

Goddamn it’s hard to be a St Kilda supporter.

Personally I hope that we can move up and select Jhye Clark. This kid will be a superstar.

Adem Yze anyone?

chook23 wrote: ↑Wed 12 Oct 2022 8:04pm Should we have taken 2nd and 3rd rounder

Puts him at about 25 points wise

Given his actual output v possible potential

No. Hopefully he can avoid the unfortunate injuries this season and everyone including Hunter, remembers how important to our success he is.

Thank god the silly season is done. My take is we lost a fringe player and gained a cheap tall defender for insurance. Taking out the players who wanted to “go home” and Grundy. This years trade period dished up a bunch of ordinary players and I’m glad we passed on them. The Clark situation is inter...

Interesting to hear why Bowes chose Geelong today. Apparently they were the only club that genuinely had an interest in him and he felt the other clubs were more about Pick 7. Not a hard choice for him in the end.

Did GC do this to free up space for Bing next year? St.Kilda better be preparing our picks + salary cap space for Bing next year, or I'll be utterly annoyed with no faith. I want a pair of Kings, that would give me some hope and faith that we may win a premiership in my lifetime, they are st.kilda ...

I’ve been waiting for long to come good now I reckon he’s just about ready to hit his straps and we lose him seems very much like many other players that have left the club Will be just another “wish we kept him”moment In fairness, we have been thinking that for a few seasons yet and it still hasn'...

The Premier of Victoria says he’s a catholic but he didn’t hesitate to make an opportunistic comment. Perhaps he should either condemn Catholicism or consider resigning given the catholic church’s views on homosexuality and abortion. Do you honestly believe that if you claim to follow a religion yo...

Some absolute Pumpkins showing their true colours in this thread.