I am fascinated Are there people on here that don’t think we should recruit talia? He would be a no brainer If he doesn’t want to leave Adelaide (find that extremely hard to believe give his comments when first delisted) or has failed a medical then fine Otherwise ask yourselves this, if Howard goe...

Be very surprised if anything happens - there has hardly been a barrage of noise / comment about this potential trade. I always had high hopes for Battle but was nearly always left disappointed / wanting more.

I'm staggered by the disrespect for Dunstan in this thread. It was Lenny Hayes remember who handed over his jumper to this man. It wasn't an accident. He played his heart out for us season after season and for a long time I thought he'd be our next skipper and certainly felt he was the ONLY player ...

Toy Saint wrote: ↑Tue 05 Oct 2021 8:07pm from an unreliable source.....Josh Battle to Brisbane for their 1st round pick.

anybody else heard this?

Surely you jest?

Nothing strange. You're missing the point too, Mr Magic. We had given up on him developing and becoming a very good player. At Essendon (of all places), Hind became an awesome player. He's now at a whole different level. Essendon knew how to get the best/most out of him. And we're now not getting t...

SaintPav wrote: ↑Sat 01 May 2021 10:31pm Bytel has a few tricks and Byrnes looked pretty good.

Unless there's a good reason not too, just play them every week.

Agree - just play them.

At 29 years old he still has at least 2 years left in him at the top level. We are now in the premiership window so a player like Sav could be very valuable. I can see why they did what the did but I would have rather they paid out McKenzie and kept Sav. He couldnt make the best players in bush foo...

Webster was clearly pushed in the back and Battle held in a f****** headlock. No worries for the maggots who gifted the weagles two f****** underserved goals. Nothing changes. Just watching the replay. Was clearly not a free to Darling against Battle, play on as they both engaged or free to Battle,...

Wayne42 wrote: ↑Mon 05 Apr 2021 1:57pm

Joffa Burns wrote: ↑Mon 05 Apr 2021 1:52pm

SaintPav wrote: ↑Mon 05 Apr 2021 1:30pm We’re screwed.

10 goal loss coming up.

Why, is there a half time mercy rule this year?

10 goals might be a bit light The Eagles are a lot better than the Dopers. NicNat shoving it down their throats is going to be a ruck work masterclass

busso mick wrote: ↑Tue 15 Dec 2020 8:18pm He should have signed with East Perth, then he could have been a Royal Doulton

Very good

saintspremiers wrote: ↑Tue 17 Dec 2019 12:03pm Can’t mention his/her name - but you all know who it is!

I reckon you should be given an OA for starting this poll

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/st-kilda-recruit-brad-hill-preparing-for-mega-roadtrip-before-tackling-preseason/news-story/31a0b3aabec71e661e96f4019067a657 "A French Bulldog, a Great Dane and an old schoolmate will accompany Brad Hill for an epic road-trip across the Nullabor...

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/st-kilda-recruit-brad-hill-preparing-for-mega-roadtrip-before-tackling-preseason/news-story/31a0b3aabec71e661e96f4019067a657 "A French Bulldog, a Great Dane and an old schoolmate will accompany Brad Hill for an epic road-trip across the Nullabor...

Bernard Shakey wrote: ↑Thu 17 Oct 2019 11:10am Gubby!!!

I reckon he had a fair bit to do with the early sniffing out and dealing with managers. Gallagher & Lethlean did the final wheeling and dealing.

People ......... he will be 30 at the start if next year with a drug and alcohol past and mental issues He won't make one iota difference to Geelong winning the Premierahip With their aging.list and having just got rid of Kelly they are on the precipice There would not have been a single club that ...

Not sure why we allow Geelong & Dockers to screw us to the bone but potentially look like we are releasing Josh to the doggies below his value. He is contracted - hold him

Shows how highly Acres is rated internally at StKilda. I believe this will be incorrect. Surely the future second rounder comes off the table if Acres is thrown in. If not, Acres is rated so lowly by the club & Ratten they have given him away. I guess 6 seasons of mediocrity has a price. When y...

Saintmatt wrote: ↑Tue 15 Oct 2019 1:03pm

longtimesaint wrote: ↑Tue 15 Oct 2019 1:02pm Why don’t we tell Geelong to shove their pick 58?

Precisely. I'd rather pay Jack to live in Lorne next year on full pay than take that sh!t pick AND have to pay some of his salary.

Bloody insult - Geelong are valuing Stuv the same as Zac Smith. Give me a break. Walk away from it Saints.

That is ordinary - please tell me that we aren't also paying a portion of his salary

Heraldsun is reporting 12 and 18 to Port 10 to freo and saints first next year Hill, ryder, howard to saints Would do next years second in replace to next years first in a heart beat, but it could end up being a pick in the top 5! which would be way overs Gee this seems overs for what we are getting

The latest rumour is that the Hill to saints paperwork will be lodged tomorrow morning. Not sure what it will cost us.

I was just pointing out that Ross’ disposal efficiency is higher than Hill’s. 2019: Hill 67%. Ross 73% Career: Hill 71% Ross 73% I think it is also important to note that Champion data consider any kick over 45 meters to be effective. Maybe I’m off my rocker, but these numbers say Ross hits his tar...

Kind of feel we are all overrating our potential trades. yes Hill is handy, an elite winger, but hardly a kelly, heck, he's never even made the aa squad. way too overpriced given we don't have a fyfe to hand him the ball on a platter. he's worth that pick 12 and a steak knives player or a future se...

His last couple of years have been ordinary before that he was serviceable. The fact no one is interested says it all.

We could also end up with not much