3rd in the Brownlow
and finished High las season (approx 6th)

how good would you like him to be......

5. Max Hudghton
4. Lenny Hayes
3. Rob Harvey
2. Nick Dal Santo
1. David Armitage

Yes but bagging the F*** out of a guy who has been one of the best performed players over a long period after a few 'quiet games' is absurd and surely a joke, or from guys who should keep their opinions to themselves.... And the bloke who believes that I embrace mediocrity, should know that I have p...

Your one of the idiots I am talking about....

4 bad games......no, just not four dominant games.....and he isn't the first player to get towelled up by Linga....who is an AA

Yes he is

Should be forthcoming from a few supporters (who continually get egg on their faces)....tonight he was FIRST RATE....it isn't always easy with a hard tag....

You do not finish Top 5 in a B&F four years straight if you are lazy...get some F***ing perspective

Hayes is a blue collar midfielder, with average disposal that kicks very few goals.....he is as tough as nails.........great work ethic...he has been great player who has outstanding games, but rarely inspirational moments...rarely speaks, and is generally a shy man. Well respected and Good on-field...

Charlie has kicked 25 goals in 50 games.....good lead up 4th fwd.....not a scoreboard danger

Was the problem..... The players or The Structure???? This week Michael will match Kosi......and Ryder will run with Reiwoldt...and Dustin Fletcher will continually be the third man up, mopping up all long balls.....so we will not be able to go long and direct, instead play slow, safe, measured, low...

Prefer the VFL... AFL is a corperate joke......a game about money...not the fans.....its about image.....and forgets about where it came from.....it has no soul IMO.... If it weren't for the St.KFC I would not even read about the game....let alone watch it.......pity there are a lot of good players ...

Outstanding clearance player with solid skills by hand and foot, is brutul in the contest with a mean streak.....will make it....but he is extremely inside and we have too many of his type...Ball, Hayes who win first possesion....and plenty who win first/second possesion Harvey, Dal, X, Joey.....pro...

Where are they at.... Luke has not playesd at the scorps in the pre-season after a solid debut for the saints...you think a guy that finished high in a WAFL senior team B&F at 21yo could get a game in the seniors at Casey I think I saw Khan at sandy during the seniors walking around the ground.....

Dumbest of dumb idea.... Not the strongest contested mark, he would be just drawn back to the goalsquare by direct opponent...... How would he go one on one with monsters such as Brown, Pav, Hall, Tredders.... Could work against the dogs/adelaide....but Take him from the fwd line we lose potency.......

B: Geary (183)/Akermanis (177) - Hudghton (191)/Johnson (182) - S.Fisher (192)/Welsh (188) HB: Gram (186)/Hill (186) - Blake (191)/Hahn (188) - R.Clarke (188)/Murphy (186) C: Dal Santo (186)/Boyd (184) - Hayes (186)/Cross (187) - X.Clarke (182)/Eagleton (180) HF: Harvey (181)/Griffen (188) - Riewold...

On thin ice atm......who will BJ, Maguire, Bakes replace....they are walk up starts when fit.....Raph will play if we have a few injuries...

He had a bad game....very much a confidence player.....structure did not help

Rix is safe as houses on our list.....every thing you want in a 3rd/4th Ruckman....or back up defender Strong, hardworking, durable, tough and best of all Cheap Gwilt is slower than my grandmother, he will be delisted at seasons end... he is not tall enough for his weight.....what position can he pl...

Ross should not play favourites.....his history with Dempster should cloud the fact he is NOT in our best 22 - clearly 22-30....and thats on the last 3 years.... He opposes Goddard Blake L.Fisher Baker all of whom have had better careers than Sean to this date Raph and Gilbo are possibly behind Demp...

Raph had a shocking first half.......a better second... he looks short on confidence....looks to handball at every opportunity (which is an indicator).... He was very indecisive early.....not sure wheher to fly or not, or whether to mark or punch.... He improved after HT....I reckon Ross spoke to hi...

Worked well for the last three q's.....due to Ross generally benching on of the talls......against that opposition we should have kicked 35..... Gehrig was good... Milne was good.... Schnieder was OK.... Riewoldt was average.... Kosi was deplorable.... IMO when the ball hits the deck with a Tall fwd...

BOG votes
5-Montagna
4-L.Hayes
3-M.Hudghton
2-S.Fisher
1-X.Clarke

Other good Players
Ball (awesome inside some mistakes by foot)
Gardiner (dominant ruckman)
Gram (Drive, but some turn overs)

Milne and Gehrig were good fwds
Both taggers did well

WOG Votes
3-Kosi
2-Raph
1-Gilbert

Have a look at the tape again.....

He played a good game - a real ruckmans game......cleared space for the smaller players, and drifted into dangerous spots...his hitout work was good....

Still looks proppy running at times....

I would bet you $100 he was involved in the passages of play that resulted in the first three goals (I just looked at it again to make sure - maybe you should have a look) given that one was a free kick which was absurd..... I do believe I said he had an overall VG game....but he makes big errors, d...

Had a VG game .... as usual he did A job....but...

How slow a decision maker is he....and...

he is very clumsy....and...

his disposal is terrible....but...

His work ethic and courage is first rate.....

Need him in the team, but you cannot have too many of his type..