I can't believe we can't get Members and Max to work together.
The system we were using up till now clearly wasn't working for King either.
Figure out a new one that suits them both.

That is shattering.

Maybe we make a play for Barrass now?

He was a great player in a very lean time.
He deserved a lot more.
Hope he is happy and proud of what he achieved.

Sinclair 4
jones 3
clark 3
philipou 2
wood 2
higgins 1

I vote to Keep Jack Hayes

Wilkie 3
Steele 3
Marshall 3
Higgins 2
Membrey 2
Wilson 1
Sharman 1

freely wrote: ↑Tue 13 Aug 2024 9:24am I sort of get it but it's a bit daft. I mean, who's gonna come marching in? The Sts?

People follow the Hawks, not the Hawths....?

Marshall
Sinclair
Wilkie
Battle
Membrey

Furthermore, the dot below the T has always annoyed me, it’s incorrect, there’s no dot in St Kilda. I suppose you know that 'st' isn't a word. The correct spelling is St Kilda. No dot. Just like St John Ambulance or St Vincent’s Hospital. It is an abbreviation that doesn’t always use a dot. The St ...

If it's the St.K.F.C. across the shield they're removing then I am absolutely against it. That little bit of typography is my favourite thing in the whole design -- and had been since childhood. Other things I agree could be changed if necessary, though I'd prefer it if they weren't The mascot is wh...

He needs to come with a redemption story that -- against expectations -- holds water.
I would be exploring that possibility.
If it won't, then they won't pursue it (I hope).
No harm in exploring.
Plenty of harm in getting it wrong.

5 Battle
3 Sinclair
2 Steele
2 Marshall
2 Phillipou
1 Membrey

Could somebody please do one of those statistical analyses of our performances over the last month that show how well we've been doing. I've seen it said that we were the the leading contested possession winners over the last 4 games, and various other impressive ratings. I'd like to be able to bask...

Sainter_Dad wrote: ↑Sun 28 Jul 2024 5:08pm Avid - you can vote for 15 players and give them all one - but it does not assist improve the voting

Yes. I was being (mildly) funny.

Appreciate your work SD, and get a bit annoyed for you when other peoples' votes don't add up to 15.

4 Sharman
4 NWM
2 Steele
2 Marshall
1 Battle
1 Owens
1 Wilkie
Pity there aren't more votes to give to others.

4 Membrey
3 Wood
2 Steele
2 Marshall
2 Sinclair
1 Jones !!
1 Wilkie

4 Marshall
4 NWM
3 Phillipou
2 Clark
1 Byrnes
1 Sharman

I'm just looking at multiple repeats of the incident. It is very hard to see what could have possibly caused the injury -- a vague loose swipe from the side of an open palm? Heeney was clearly just turning back to push Webster away for a little more separation, and collected his nose down at waist l...

I'm just looking at multiple repeats of the incident. It is very hard to see what could have possibly caused the injury -- a vague loose swipe from the side of an open palm? Heeney was clearly just turning back to push Webster away for a little more separation, and collected his nose down at waist l...

I thought he deserved votes for his role, in the 3rd quarter especially
Combining with Henry and Pou, etc -- just a fantastic game-turning effort effort.

3 wilkie
3 marshall
3 philipou
2 henry
2 higgins
1 nwm
1 howard

a few unexpected names in there
and several others who deserved votes left out

Why do so many instantly play the victim card as soon as some criticism is pointed our way? We're 15th!!! The competition is as even as I can remember Last year was similar to this year in that after Rd 16 ... 15 sides had % above 92 We have played 15 games and have lost 6 games under 10pts and won...

Looks like we might be able to get one of them.
Or two?

4 sinclair
4 marshall
3 wilkie
2 wanganeen milera
2 wood

This adds up to 19 - only 15 to give You could multiply each individual vote by 15 divided by 19 That's going to be a messy spreadsheet ...you should just ignore all his votes if he doesn't amend them . It's not rocket science :mrgreen: Or just take his top six. (They add up to 15) It's a little an...