We have never replaced Carlisle - and that has been to our detriment My view is that you build sides from defence So there is your answer from me Yes, we also need support for Marshall and for King but the question is where are the options across the competition And mids - well, we have started wit...

Main Goal ... win Premiership

If that's not achievable then .... Destroy Carlscum's Salary Cap

Its a solid and very likeable fallback plan .... count me in

Well hopefully those 25 people don't all sit together

Better if they spread out a bit

I also got from a pretty good source that the Hawks thought we were the softest team they have played all year

Hopefully it's got back to the players & coaches

Not a chance in hell

Likely it was a drunken, spur of the moment, ill-considered rant by a knob jockey who stepped out of line ..... hence the deletion of his whole X account ..... reckon he would have got a fairly hefty smackdown by his partners Also learnt his lesson that their are parasite journos that will jump on a...

I saw the odds also and wondered how we could be favourites. I know quite often we bitch and moan about previous trades and we do have to move on but:- 2019 draft pick 10 which we had Tom Green GWS Hill has been good for us but maybe now Green /Serong plus Acres plus our future 2nd would make our t...

At Marvel with a firecracker up our bum = favourites

More interested how the players & coaches respond

Unfortunately Byrnes is undersized for the wing and can't find enough ball to be a midfielder ... he doesn't have the composure either

Maybe he could be used as a tagger against smaller mids as he has a decent engine .... Clint Jones mode

And if you believe the the only way to win a Premiership is bottoming out and tanking then knock yourself out

SaintPav wrote: ↑Tue 14 May 2024 12:47am Weren’t we the best defensive team last year?

That’s a pretty solid effort.

Cmon Saint Pav ... our defensive unit just rode their luck

Forget also that this year they are currently ranked 6th in lowest points against

A bit of a myth that our draw was easy at the start of last year ... in the first 7 games we played 3 teams that were in the Finals from 2022 and played 3 teams that ended up playing Finals alongside us in 2023 ... including the Premier 6 of first 7 games were against sides that finished in the Top...

It's not rocket surgery and with the exception of say the Baby Bombers of 1993, history proves you can't take short cuts and snatch a flag with half of your players being kids. You can also snatch 3 Flags by playing a brand of tippy tappy crappy chaos football as Richmond did all whilst being last ...

A bit of a myth that our draw was easy at the start of last year ... in the first 7 games we played 3 teams that were in the Finals from 2022 and played 3 teams that ended up playing Finals alongside us in 2023 ... including the Premier 6 of first 7 games were against sides that finished in the Top ...

Got more chance of winning 1st division in the lotto than us making they 8 this season. Those are the facts. We are well short on talent and way off the pace. We over achieved last season. It's about rebuilding over the next few years so buckle up. That's not fact (not yet anyway) ... that's your o...

If we win 10 or more of our next 14 ... I doubt we would be stumbling in

Yes the Cold Hard Facts .... We are all in agreeance that currenrly we aren't playing great footy ... let's call it a form slump ... we are struggling to score We sit 3 & 6 with 96% (28pts to the negative) ... our % is quite decent considering the win loss ratio If we are to play Finals then we ...

Agree with BM .... Windhager him

G'day Saints fans ... yeah look it was a very disappointing night and the not the result we were looking for..... we made an enormous amount of skill errors which is just not usually us and hopefully its not a trend .....

So are clearances that are blind hack bomb it forward kicks to no one Marshall is elite around the ground as a general play tall .... as a ruck in a ruck contest not so much If he is going to continue to grab the ball and hack kick it forward then maybe we need to anticipate this better .... Hawks ...

I will go with an odd number .... 23,537

So are clearances that are blind hack bomb it forward kicks to no one Marshall is elite around the ground as a general play tall .... as a ruck in a ruck contest not so much If he is going to continue to grab the ball and hack kick it forward then maybe we need to anticipate this better .... Hawks c...

With Higgins & Butler out what's our solution to a goal kicking small forward? ..... clearly missed against the Hawks

Some are saying Collard but then he goes and has a shocker against Box Hill .... are we going in again with no small forward?

We need to move the ball much quicker and with far more confidence. I have to hand it to Hawthorn for the way they shut down our run last week. Every St Kilda possession was under extreme pressure and we were lucky to finish as close as we did Did Hawthorn shut down our run or did we just refuse to...

Well several articles have alluded to Stephen Kellis being his manager with Ned Costello supporting Kellis Also clearly mentioned that it was the heat of the moment tweet from the couch so I doubt Pou gave it the greenlight .... just another rash, ill-considered, moronic opinion which bottom feeding...