So is Caminiti a bust??

So we are now 2 - 5 and we have played 6 games against top 9 sides on the current ladder and lost 4 of them by 1, 7, 8 & 10 and played 3 interstate matches with a huge injury list Now we start to get some players back and the fixture becomes a little easier for us So who is in .... and who is ou...

Billings is a good player .... ruined by injury at the Saints

Same with Gresham .... ruined by injury while with us

Thanks Bob for your update! Doing the right thing with Dow giving him another week of conditioning If he gets through the Sandy match unscathed we should see him debut for us v North Can't say I am too confident about this week v Port but it gives our players from last week a chance to redeem themse...

What’s the purpose and benefit of the tactic of sitting back in a game of keeping’s off? With the match being our 3rd match in 11 days maybe the coaches were wary of our players being tired and hence they went in with a less taxing gameplan so we didn't fall off the cliff after half time Also feels...

It's all about the Mum genes

Rhys the Barometer Beast Mathieson will sort him out

We have debuted 4 this year ... just Arie to go

With more experienced players coming back though they might not get many more games (Wilson the exception) but great that they have had a taste

Well done Darcy .... still needs some filling out ... skinny as

He has had a cruisy run thus far being picked to play every week

It's now time that if his form and effort don't warrant selection then he needs to be dropped.

It might actually do him some good

...... Are you saying none of the players tried their guts out and none of the players deserve praise for 100% effort? Did you just watch the scoreboard during the game? :mrgreen: You know when they used to put in the local papers for the U9 games .... Best: Team Effort Well this match was the oppo...

Better overhead than the Bont?? All I ever see is Phillipou drop marks Struggles to read the flight of the ball and runs too far underneath it .... constantly Currently he only gets a bare pass mark because of his age He is no Harley Reid that's for sure He needs to sign a contract and stop being fu...

Bookmarked

It's becoming a joke

Cut off the supply .... they just refuse to do it

74 to 39 clangers ... enough said

Rancid putrid performance

5 - no one
4 -no one
3 - no one
2 - no one
1 - no one
0 - everyone incl. coaches

Embarrassing performance ... that said 4th game in 20 days with 2 interstate trips and a large injury list

But seriously we have some dumb players ... some turnovers were inexcusable

Back to the drawing board and let's hope we start to get some players back

samuraisaint wrote: ↑Mon 15 Apr 2024 6:11pm And another one

King is right - if that was Jimmy Webster it's multiple weeks

Ben Long copped weeks for a very similar incident when he went to play the ball but got Sean Darcy's head with his arse .... verdict 3 weeks

Why haven't Melbourne been contacted for comment?

And actually why should the club comment anyway considering it alledgedly happened 5 years after he retired

bobmurray wrote: ↑Wed 10 Apr 2024 9:06pm

Otiman wrote: ↑Tue 09 Apr 2024 3:09pm These are the kinds of threads that sets up Saintsational as "that crackpot board".

That's how Big Footy views this forum.

Most of the posters on Saints Big Footy are on here as well

I thInk that's the call the coaches need to use if we are down on form during a match and get the players motivated

IT'S ALIEN TIME

See link below that reels off some interesting 2024 stats https://www.wheeloratings.com/afl_stats_team.html?year=2024 Currently the AFL average this year for shots on Goal is 24.8 and we sit in equal 8th position with 25 average (note - these shots on goal won't necessarily register a score) Downsid...

Do running backs need to be contested bulls Wanganeen Milera is far from physical Understand roles! No Nas is not, but at least he can win a one on one contest and commits his body when its his turn, Bonner does none of that. Perhaps you can inform us all how Bonner should play BM? Salem hates body...

Priority access to northern academies help

When are they going to stop that rort?

I just saw him crap himself a few times when trying to pick up the ball and ran over it ... and it stood out

Along with a few bad shanks but he isn't on his own there

After we get a few back I think he will struggle to hold his spot