Paddy was too fat at skilda. Never got fit. At least one thing is now proven. Sydney's medical and conditioning staff are better than stkildas ... hannebury.. Always liked Hickey. Couldn't work out why we let him go. We have a history of letting good rucks go. Marshall will be next. Hickey was avera...

Forward line is dysfunctional.. at best ... that is a direct reflection of the coach. Players get in each others way They have no system of kicking at goal They are hap-hazard in approach Yes there issues in transition between mids and forwards. The forwards need to demand the ball how they want it....

surely when they interview a player ... any player ... they get an indication of where their head is at. Interstate players should be assessed for how they will cope. What the club has to help them cope. Cant let a first round player walk after 1 year. A very very poor reflection of the club if that...

frame speed is not up to it

the Brisbane player thought it was a goal .... look at the footage. No one has said anything about his reaction.

My only surprise is that it wasnt StKilda. ... this time ....

They took Guerra because he was a great kick.Clarkson also recruited Dew on the other HBF his theory was elite long kicks to beat the flood and get the forwards (buddy) in open space. Liehert used his thumping kick on many occasions to get over the press. Long does not only get a lot of possession'...

The girls are getting better. The game is ok to watch.
Still a long way to go.... but there is big improvement.

Very long way to go before I have any real passion or will celebrate success.

Saints should look at list and work out when to have a crack. It is not next year. They can't trade out their future guns. They need experience They have good access to players through the academy. Use crouch Ross etc to teach these players coming through. Build a high performing base. Loyalty to st...

Interesting they are seeking to trade players that have injury interrupted seasons. Eg gresh and clark The trade value would be down at the moment. Both have serious upside if they get them right. Billings has zero currency. Jones a dud on a monster contract Maybe they should coffield name out there...

Doubt he will get another gig.
Serviceable. But there is no more upside. Realistically becomes a list blocker.
Unless he can being a coaching role to the ground ... which he hasn't given any indication.

Did well.

Great effort really. Long time in the system and ultimately did exceptionally well.
Very few players get to 200 games.

Good average player.

Just couldn't take the next step.

Lade is currently our forward line coach, and well to put it simply. Our forward line does not function consistently!! Is it him or is it the overall game plan? There must be some better realistic options out there. Who should we approach? Anyone. Anyone would be better. Cant think of a positive th...

Bad run with injury and is too fat.

Needs to have a good predestination nd will get back to his best.

Would be traded for 3 round at best at the moment.

Enforcer. Good for pitch hitting in the centre.
Every good team has someone that causes the opposition to second think. That moment of hesitation.
Difficult role to play in today's game. Long does it well.

Playing without confidence.
Has zero currency and is at the cross roads.
Has talent. Is there desire?
Could be used better. But needs belief in himself and a want to win.
At the moment is looking like a bust.

He is still young. Dont really want his body bashed up too quickly.
We have very little in the way of a backup with Ryder gone. The alternatives are just rucks and cant play anywhere else.

Symbolic of the bench that he has been on for the majority of time played for the saints.

One good thing... once you have been chaired off you can't come back!!

He drives me crazy.
Marks 50m in the clear.
Every single time he goes back and waits for a player to take the mark.
Rarely plays on. Never moves the ball quickly.

My issue is the wokeness and social justice. The talk about town at the moment is getting Clarko to Essendon as he will bring back the ruthlessness. Ruthless is not something that has ever been associated with stklida. Ross Lyon was uncompromising. Grant Thomas has that aspect as well. The coaches u...

Brad is now 30 and the best is behind him.
There is no way we would get a 1st round pick.

More like mid second and have to pay half his salary.

Let's face it. He is 'over the Hill'. ... boom boom.

I dont believe our "foot skills' are any worse than the next team, taking out goal kicking. Foot skills around the ground break down to structure and game plan. Is the player where I need them, or where they should be. Are they getting into a position that I can actually kick it to them. This r...

Highmore Keep Bytel Keep Byrnes Keep (last chance) Geary Gone already Josiah Kyle Gone already Hannebery Surely we have spent enough already !!!! Our soft cap cant take anymore Allison Gone Kent Gone Ryder Needs to go Joyce We need to get another ruck.

Lloyd is an arrogant puffed up show pony

Even if Lloyd cant cure Max kicking woes (which I believe Lloyd will do)

Maybe he can help him improve on his Rooster status.

Brilliance.
Apprenticeship started.
Go learn from the best.

This is what we did with Jack Steele.

First round draft pick?

I have the gift wrapping purchased already. Can you pass the sticky-tape