saintDal wrote:Robert Harvey to the Dockers

Blasphemous

mad saint guy wrote:Cook, Monkhurst, Elliot, Sierakowski, Capuano, Knobel, Oliver, Brooks, Stone, Ackland, Rix, Clarke and Gardiner

hmmm for us... clearly Sierakowski was the best of that lot, quite liked David and was sad to see him go... nick named him lionheart

n1ck wrote:I think what GT actually said, was that if it hadnt been for the rain forecast, he would have played him.

don't let facts distort ppl's B#!&H fest

I've had a read of the trade thread which at this point has shifted more towards players delisting...

what's news from today anyone

King is another bandaid solution... if we get him, we still need an up and comer Ideal Ruck stocks 2 ruckman in the starting 22... Primary Ruck: #1 tap ruck who is excellent around the ground Secondary Ruck: KPP that pinch hits in the ruck (Maybe u have a few other pinch hitters too e.g. Blake, Magu...

i think it was helped along by the fact that he played a blinder against us too

SaintBot wrote:

skeptic wrote:how about Brent Prismal?

Pettifer was linked to us some time ago

offer Brooks for the pair

how about Brent Prismal?

Pettifer was linked to us some time ago

When forumites are speculating on potential trades can we stop involving Barry Brooks as part of the package... NOBODY WANTS HIM

So far this week I've heard Brooks as part of a deal for Brock McLean, Adam Schneider and somebody suggested Cam Wood earlier in the week.

Its embarrassing

Teflon wrote:Second round pick plus watts..........maybe a Brooks...

melb would be stupid not to jump at that

He just didn't want it bad enough. Came back in 98 no fitter than 97. Was never a particularly strong contested mark and when opposition players played infront of him... they basically rendered him ineffective. I heard rumours RE problem gambling and heavy drinking during the TW years... became very...

fair question plugger only basing my reports on what I've heard... haven't seen him myself. The answers simple, we need a new quality FB... the cupboard is almost bare. Hudghtons on his last legs (really more suited to a BP now), Maguire is all over the place, Fisher x 2 aren't KPPs. No obvious back...

got him marked for FB in years to come personally

this could work the other way though

they could lose a lot of quality to get him... could imagine this destabling the club more so

i quite enjoyed the read, got assignments and a hot date to think about atm... will analyze later my early impression is that they are quite clearly playing cards close to their chest but they explain why this is so... good to see Westaway is a big saints fan and that they acknowledge Butters contri...

can't we just habe a poll as to whether or not ban barks... I think most forumites like me are sick of - the same reptitive dribble - hijacking countless good threads - the unnecessary swearing and abuse - the facts that aren't facts, mysterious sources and the posts that are ignored because they bl...

Jason Gram – Traded by Brisbane in 2003 for Draft Selection #23 – Matthew Moody (#23), Chad Jones (#24), Harry Miller (#25), Daniel McConnell (#26), Adam Campbell (#27) & Jed Adcock (#33) Clear winner Aaron Hamill – Traded by Carlton in 2000 for Sam Cranage and Draft Selection #4 – Luke...

we would have benn in this position and probably premiers in 2004 if it was not for the interruption to our momentum when the g train kicked his hundred's goal. this train of thought has always astounded me... so we've determined that we would have carried on with "the momentum" the fact ...

saintsrus wrote:

n1ck wrote:seaby has just re-signed with WCE anyway i think...

He can still be traded does not matter

i'm pretty sure that u can't be traded in the 1st year of ur new contract

the power of suggestion is a powerful thing a few forumites point blame at KS for a few things and then the bandwagon forumites spin everything he does into a negative Example He gets all the contracts done, ppl say it should have been done midseason even though this time of year is quite standard a...

i'm starting to worry...

i've heard this one to from a guy that knows SFA

starting to gather momentum

u guys really astound me... do u really think NDS is capable of carrying this midfield by himself every week??? As if Gary Ablett jnr is so great... any coincidence that his improvement has coincided with the improvement of Bartel, Ling + the addition of Selwood? lets take those 3 away then see how ...

the thing is, of all the holes in our list... the forward line is the absolute least of our worries... we still have Riewoldt and Kosi and say Kosi is needed in the ruck, we currently have 2 potential replacements in Watts and Brooks who can be given a crack and some like Ferguson who can pinch hit....

the thing is, of all the holes in our list... the forward line is the absolute least of our worries... we still have Riewoldt and Kosi and say Kosi is needed in the ruck, we currently have 2 potential replacements in Watts and Brooks who can be given a crack and some like Ferguson who can pinch hit....

Just to add to MM's op... I believe that SFF are also saying that while were making money and paying off the debt, the majority of the net was not made by increased revenue and by cost cutting... furthermore, we infact could have been making a lot more out of our push over the last 2-3 years (media,...