5 Wilkie
4 Wilson
3 NWM
2 Sinclair
1 Owens

If umpires cannot adjudicate incorrect disposal then it's time to get rid of the rule. Tackles where the ball comes out being called play on, players throwing the ball over their heads like seasoned boundary umpires. The game is dying a slow death under the belief it needs to speed up.

5 Windhager
4 Hill
3 Wilson
2 Garcia
1 Steele

Today he had a set shot (maybe his only one) from around 40 metres out, slightly to the right of goal, and it slewed off badly to the left. One would have hoped he would have learnt from last week when he had two shots from the same position which also slewed off exactly the same. And surely it is ...

B.M., I watched, he was great in the ruck today. He can always get a stack of football. Just acknowledge that you always seem to point out when we get smashed in the ruck, it is in the centre. Yet you never appreciated the work of Ryder, bemoaning the worth of a ruck tap. We always look a better sid...

I don't think either of those half backs caused the turnovers that ultimately resulted in game killing goals that lost the game for us. Nor did they have any influence on the goals our forwards missed. Again, you have said it often, the half back role is a gimme when it comes to possessions. Someone...

B.M wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 7:02pm Yep

I’d play him high and Caminiti and Hayes/Marshall deep

You are quite hard to follow at times. When we had Ryder, you kept saying Marshall was not a forward and we were killing him and ourselves playing him forward. (paraphrasing)

I still believe he's the player we can build a Premiership forward line around. That said, regardless of injury, I would have dropped him for next week, along with a few others who need to know, A) They are not indispensable B) Have not made it yet.

5 Hill
4 Steele
3 Marshall
2 Windhager
1 Garcia

Fair selection. Jones was ordinary for an experienced player. A poor standard for the young players. He's better than last Sunday.

Prefer the Saturday game over the Thursday game if a vote is needed.

Round 10 v Freo is my choice.

Count me in please, either game suits.

5 Steele
4 Hill
3 NWM
2 RoMa
1 Battle

Out coached You’re taking the piss King Henry Wood Webster Howard Clarke Crouch Dow Paton All out That's not why we lost today. Correct, the players on the field were the reason we lost. We kick goals, instead of points, when on top we win. Then Essendon panic & our exits from the backline are ...

5 Ross
4 Steele
3 Higgins
2 Hill
1 Battle

Sinclair & Bonner's turnovers were critical & cost them any chance of votes. NWM nearly but sadly got shut out when we really needed him - he, Marshall & King are our most important assets. Just wish we had a genuine forward / ruck ready to go.

I will guarantee if Ross Lyon had the magical formula for kicking goals, he, A) Would have employed it over his coaching career & B) Would not be coaching us but making millions on a retainer. Lyon can only put a structure in place for players to have the easier shot at goal. What they do from t...

Always sad when a true Saint passes on. He only ever wanted the best for the Saints and did what he thought was the right thing to do for the club at all times. We won our first cup since 1966 under his reign and made a Grand Final for the first time in 26 years including being minor premiers for t...

The AFL really need to out and say the compilation is based around a few clubs being successful. StKilda are merely there for someone to provide a contest. If this suspension is upheld I doubt any StKilda supporter can ever believe in a fair comp. I doubt few believe that now. Any pretence was lost...

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 21 Mar 2024 10:55pm Back handed?

Nice

In what way?

SydneySainter wrote: ↑Thu 21 Mar 2024 10:47pm

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Thu 21 Mar 2024 10:40pm Sydney Sainter. You will have to live by that s*** post last week.

I admit, I was wrong and I’m very happy to be.

Not happy, just contrite. You'll be back.

5 NWM
4 Marshall
3 Windhager
2 Steele
1 Higgins

Regardless of what anyone thinks of Seb, he should be congratulated & appreciated for 200 games in a period we were genuinely woeful.

Not his greatest fan and can see his limitations but he's a better man than me for the games he's played for the Saints...congrats Seb!

5 NWM
4 Steele
3 Henry
2 RoMa
1 King

Please get Owens in the guts. Let Wilson ride the wing & Wood forward.

Loving the energy by the Saints supporters here. We are in this once the umps stop taking their advice from the Geelong players.

The Duelling Banjos are alive and well at Sleepy Hollow.