wasaintsfan wrote:i support the St Kilda Saints Football Club not the AFL or NEW ZEALAND or "THE SAINTS".. If we changed names.. membership would be gone as would my love for afl. Might sound petty but i started liking afl because of the club and its history....

We are not the St Kilda Saints Football Club.

Bernard Shakey wrote:

SainterK wrote:Surprised if Kosi doesn't play.

Very.

He will play for Sandy on Sunday. Punishment for acts of stupidity in three of the four games he's played.

Only three out of four. That's the nicest thing you've ever said about Kosi.

To suggest Watters is not at fault and it's "someone who does the paperworks" job is rubbish - Watters lives and dies by the on field moves he makes from the box it's his responsibility to KNOW when he can/ can't substitute a player... next we'll blame "Joe the camera man" It is...

Dunstall and Salmon in 1998 Carey and Longmire in 1999 Carey and Rocca in 2001 Hall and OLoughlin in 2009 Hall and Jonhson in 2010 Had kicked 500+ goals in the same team. Not for the same team though. Salmon only kicked 41 goals for Hawthorn. Hall didn't kick 500 goals for anyone Rocca only kicked ...

stinger wrote:

On the Bench wrote:James Magner is a class act. Interesting to see how many of the Saints talked to him on the ground after the game. Obviously a great bloke and seems to be well respected.

someone like to run past me again the reasons we passed on this bloke......

He's a bleeder.

But mcadam05's post was about players who had kicked goals for the same club. And Lockett kicked less than 500 goals for the Swans.

so at sydney - every single player played with lockett had a total goals over 1000. But not playing for the same club. History seems to forget that almost two thirds of Plugger's goals were for the Saints. But by the end of Round 4 1934 Jack Carmody (2) and Gordon Coventry (998) had kicked a thousa...

Not only has Stephen achieved the 500 goals milestone, he is also now in the top 50 goalkickers ever (Jonathon Brown is number 49, as an indication of player quality). By career end, it is likely that Stephen will move into the top 40. I note that Nick Riewoldt is not far behind. He needs just 16 g...

Once he was charged with striking, this was the only way it could go.

I'm sure with the right coaching, Milne could perform to the same level in finals as Leon Davis or Alan Didak

Are the other teams lifting or are we not as good as we think we are?

Is Montagna in trouble?

I'm hoping it was just a head clash but if they were wrestling at the time it might be reportable.

mad saint guy wrote:Did anyone else think Roo's snap kick looked like a goal? At first I thought it looked in and then on replay I still didn't think it looked like a behind. And now they do call a review for an obvious point..

It smacked straight into the post didn't it?

Or Barry Pascoe

Is this the same guy?

I can never match faces

http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/1966-Scanlen ... 2eaea85eff

mcadam05 wrote:going on the other ones i have it dates early 70's , for some reason I thought it was Bob Pascoe

darryl played one game in 1970 so time frame is right but Bob Pascoe could be right.

Des Nisbet?

Edit Darryl Nisbet. Des I think was an administrator who according to AFL tables played in the 50's

Still just an educated guess

Yes,
Both played at the saints as the 2nd of their 3 clubs.

It looks like we're playing next year. THE Brisbane Lions have emerged as the front-runners to travel to New Zealand next season to take on St Kilda as part of an Anzac Day double-header which last night received the thumbs up from Collingwood president Eddie McGuire. Read more: http://www.brisbanet...

Nineteen players in the history of the AFL/VFL have played 170 games or more without playing in a final. Two Saints head the list Barker 230, Cunningham 224 There are two other former Saints on the list who also played for other clubs. Who are they? BTW. Greg Burns and Robert Elphinstone 169 and 157...

It should be said that the added degree of difficulty associated with recently introduced rules, and the insistence of rules that adjudicate not on what an umpires sees, but what is believes was the intent of the player, makes umpiring much more difficult than it should be. What would be wrong with...

So he had no input??? Why is he paid again??? I don't care of your his brothers uncles best friends accountant.... Good on you And rooey I could have made a case for him not moving well 12 months ago, don't worry about R1..... 10 years at CHF will do that...... His hamstring/knee injury has obvious...

We might get lucky and lose against Melbourne so we can be fired up for the following game.

SainterK wrote:

kosifantutti wrote:How did this work out for everyone?

Everyone as in?

As in those that were going to boo and jeer and heckle Lyon and laugh at the way he walked. I was just curious if they felt the loss any less than others.

B Gram Wilkes Hallahan HB Gwilt Dowler Ferguson C Winmar Curren Andreoli HF Peake Archer Ray F Shenton Siposs Dunell R Sikora Ledger Cockie Int Irving Cook Michaliades Howes* Minchington Ross Waller Shepheard Stapleton Reckon that side could knock off 5 AFL sides? would thrash the demons. beat gws ...